@anthak, @YAD69, @port_leschenault, @leematty1, @Brett Sanders, @Bearfly, @MrsBear, @That KI Guy The 2017 All-Stars Match is to be played during Round 9, each team will have at least 1 representative in the final 22 (named in the classic Super coach format except with no C/VC and with an emergency on each line, ie 26 players total). Note Port Adelaide and Gold Coast players have the bye. @Bearfly and the board also have to announce the host town (Rutherglen hosted in 2016 as the 9th placed side at the end of Round 15). Post away
Hey all, so far, the boozers nominations would be; Defs avg >85 Hurley 87 Frost 86 Suckling 86 Mids avg >110 Rocky 128 Goddard 111 Tmitch 110 Fwds avg >90 Cameron 105 Buddy 90
I reckon Heard Is have a few more players who can be considered this season after only 1 was selected last season (Cyril Rioli who is no longer at the club) D: Jeremy McGovern; Jake Lloyd; Jason Johannisen M: Nat Fyfe; Matt Crouch
The Virgin's nominate: Lachie Neale (fre) MID 113 Josh J. Kennedy (wce) FWD 108 Matt Priddis (wce) MID 105 David Mundy (fre) MID 103 Aaron Sandilands (fre) RUC 96 Kade Simpson (car) DEF 93
Yep my mids generally suck. N Roo (StK) FWD 111 Betts (Adel) FWD 93 Howe (Coll) DEF 98 Sloane (adel) MID 132
att @port_leschenault @Brett Sanders @Bearfly @MrsBear Any thoughts on players from your teams for this game in round 9?
I wouldn't worry too much Ant, if I remember correctly your bunch were pretty half arsed last year and still managed to pick a good enough team to take out the first ever All Stars match.
Wedge Island nominate the following to consider (I think half the defence will be Pointers ) Rory Laird (Adel) Def 111 ave pre round 8 Taylor Adams (Coll) D/M 110 ave Sam Menagola (Geel) Mid 103 ave (and another ton last night - handy I/C player to consider) Toby Greene (GWS) Fwd 99 ave (can't recall if he's still suspended for round 9 - if not then definitely in the mix) Honorable mention to Ollie Wines who would've been in the mix if he was playing - can Port trade him to another club for one game Will get @MrsBear on to nominating her players this arvo
One more round to have a look at our players before the big game. @anthak, @YAD69, @port_leschenault, @leematty1, @Brett Sanders, @Bearfly, @MrsBear, @That KI Guy Here's our best in each position at present (I think Ive captured them all): D: Adams (WIW) 111; Laird (WIW) 109; Lloyd (HIS) 99; ZJones (WPW) 97; JJ (HIS) 94; Simpson (ULV) 94; Hurley (MTB) 94; Howe (NIN) 93; McGovern (HIS) 90; Hibberd (MLA) 90; Rance (PLP) 88; Frost (MTB) 87, Suckling (MTB) 84. (I added Frost and Suckers because they were nominated above) M: Sloane (NIN) 125; Rocky (MTB) 120; Neale (ULV) 118; Titch (MTB) 111; Oliver (WPW) 111; Goddard (MTB) 109; ZMerrett (WPW) 109; Dusty (MLA) 108; Heppell (WPW) 107; Fyfe (HIS) 105; Priddis (ULV) 104; Menegola (WIW) 103; Mundy (ULV) 101. R: McEvoy (MLA) 99; Jacobs (PLP) 95; Sandi (ULV) 94; Kreuzer (HIS) 93; Goldstein (MLA) 88. F: Waite (MLA) 147; Yeo (WPW) 114; JJK (ULV) 106; NRoo (NIN) 103; Buddy (MTB) 99; Greene (WIW) 99; JCameron (MTB) 96; Betts (NIN) 90. At this stage, it looks like we will all have at least 1 rep each on merit. Sam Jacobs is important for @MrsBear Looking at the Ticker, some players to strongly consider: Betts vs Bris (difficult to take anothers spot though) Simpson vs Freo (pushes him ahead of others ~94) Greene & Cameron vs Ric (maybe Waite becomes em) Goldstein vs Melb (would have to be Jacobs's partner or an em) JJK vs Ess (lock)
Pretty much why @MrsBear hasn't nominated anyone mate - she said that Sauce was her only player decent enough to get a gig considering Ebert isn't eligible to play
Im just thinking out loud, and Im happy to see/hear what others think. Bar any injuries, I reckon locks for the 26 are (but not necessarily locks for the 22): D: Adams (WIW) 111; Laird (WIW) 109; Lloyd (HIS) 99; ZJones (WPW) 97; Simpson (ULV) 94 M: Sloane (NIN) 125; Rocky (MTB) 120; Neale (ULV) 118; Titch (MTB) 111; Goddard (MTB) 109; ZMerrett (WPW) 109; Dusty (MLA) 108 R: Jacobs (PLP) 95; Goldstein (MLA) 88 F: Yeo (WPW) 114; JJK (ULV) 106; NRoo (NIN) 103; Buddy (MTB) 99; Greene (WIW) 99; JCameron (MTB) 96 And players in strong consideration are: D (2 more): JJ (HIS) 94 (77 this week); Hurley (MTB) 94 (playing now); Howe (NIN) 93 (91); McGovern (HIS) 90 (87); Hibberd (MLA) 90 (playing now) M (2 more): Oliver (WPW) 111 (playing now); Heppell (WPW) 107 (playing now); Fyfe (HIS) 105 (playing tomorrow); Priddis (ULV) 104 (106) R (1 more): McEvoy (MLA) 99 (111); Sandi (ULV) 94 (playing tomorrow); Kreuzer (HIS) 93 (104) F (1 more): Waite (MLA) 147 (suspended but available for rep footy in round 9); Betts (NIN) 90 (playing now)
updating all of the red r8 scores from the previous comment..... " Bar any injuries, I reckon locks for the 26 are (but not necessarily locks for the 22): D: Adams (WIW) 111; Laird (WIW) 109; Lloyd (HIS) 99; ZJones (WPW) 97; Simpson (ULV) 94 M: Sloane (NIN) 125; Rocky (MTB) 120; Neale (ULV) 118; Titch (MTB) 111; Goddard (MTB) 109; ZMerrett (WPW) 109; Dusty (MLA) 108 R: Jacobs (PLP) 95; Goldstein (MLA) 88 F: Yeo (WPW) 114; JJK (ULV) 106; NRoo (NIN) 103; Buddy (MTB) 99; Greene (WIW) 99; JCameron (MTB) 96 And players in strong consideration are: D (2 more): JJ (HIS) 94 (77 this week); Hurley (MTB) 94 (127); Howe (NIN) 93 (91); McGovern (HIS) 90 (87); Hibberd (MLA) 90 (113) M (2 more): Oliver (WPW) 111 (142); Heppell (WPW) 107 (101); Fyfe (HIS) 105 (99); Priddis (ULV) 104 (106) R (1 more): McEvoy (MLA) 99 (111); Sandi (ULV) 94 (104); Kreuzer (HIS) 93 (104) F (1 more): Waite (MLA) 147 (suspended but available for rep footy in round 9); Betts (NIN) 90 (56) " I reckon Hurley and Oliver have played themselves into the team with some top performances this week (I'm not sure why I had Oliver as a maybe anyway!) Hibberd has probably done the same, and maybe McEvoy, but Im less keen on big boy when theres also Sandi available. Betts hasnt done enough and I dont think we can select him, even though the ticker is favourable for him this week. Fyfe is the same. I find it hard to believe he wont be in the final team, but he isnt in the greatest form at the moment. Maybe we can make him an emergency. Also worth noting that Sauce Jacobs has done MrsBear proud with a huge 141 this week to shore up his spot in the team on merit, meaning we all will have at least one player in the team on merit.
So, barring injuries and team selections, Im thinking we could line up something like this: D: Adams (WIW); Laird (WIW); Lloyd (HIS); ZJones (WPW); Simpson (ULV); Hurley (MTB); Hibberd (MLA) [NOT SURE WHO SHOULD BE EMERGENCY OUT OF THESE 7] M: Sloane (NIN); Rocky (MTB); Neale (ULV); Titch (MTB); Goddard (MTB); ZMerrett (WPW); Dusty (MLA); Oliver (WPW) [EM: Fyfe (HIS)] R: Jacobs (PLP); Goldstein (MLA) [EM: Sandi (ULV) or McEvoy (MLA)] F: Yeo (WPW); JJK (ULV); NRoo (NIN); Buddy (MTB); Greene (WIW); JCameron (MTB) [EM: Waite (MLA)] What does everyone think? Does anyone have any thoughts to add?
i reckon next in line for each position (if there are any selection surprises, or injuries (Rocky maybe)) would be: D: JJ M: Priddis R: Sandi or McEvoy, whoever we dont pick for the 26 F: Betts