2017 Teams and Round 7 discussion

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, May 4, 2017.

By walesy on May 4, 2017 at 10:20 PM
  1. walesy

    walesy Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2015
    Messages:
    3,070
    Likes Received:
    1,195
    I feel like I'm saying this every week, but there are some nasty outs this week!

    Annoying, there's not many ins to make up for it!

    St Kilda v GWS Giants

    Friday May 5 at Etihad Stadium (7.50pm)

    SAINTS
    B: J.Geary, N.Brown, J.Webster

    HB: J.Newnes, J.Carlisle, D.Roberton

    C: N.Riewoldt, J.Steele, L.Montagna

    HF: J.Gresham, J.Bruce, J.Billings

    F: D.Minchington, T.Membrey, J.Sinclair

    FOL: B.Longer, S.Ross, J.Steven

    I/C: B.Acres, S.Gilbert, K.Stevens, N.Wright

    EMG: T.Hickey, P.McCartin, D.McKenzie

    IN: N.Wright

    OUT: M.Weller

    GIANTS
    B: Z.Williams, A.Corr, H.Shaw

    HB: A.Kennedy, P.Davis, T.Taranto

    C: N.Wilson, C.Ward, T.Scully

    HF: S.Johnson, R.Lobb, M.Kennedy

    F: D.Smith, J.Patton, J.Cameron

    FOL: S.Mumford, J.Kelly, D.Shiel

    I/C: H.Himmelberg, S.Coniglio, J.Hopper, A.Tomlinson

    EMG: M.de Boer, D.Simpson, H.Perryman

    IN: P.Davis, S.Congilio, H.Himmelberg

    OUT: S.Reid, N.Haynes, T.Greene

    North Melbourne v Adelaide

    Saturday May 6 at Blundstone Arena (1.45pm)

    KANGAROOS
    B: M.Williams, R.Tarrant, E.Vickers-Willis

    HB: L.Hansen, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan

    C: N.Hrovat, B.Cunnington, K.Turner

    HF: T.Garner, B.Brown, M.Wood

    F: J.Anderson, J.Waite, S.Higgins

    FOL: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, S.Gibson

    I/C: L.McDonald, R.Clarke, T.Dumont, S.Atley

    EMG: B.Preuss, C.Wagner, D.Mountford

    IN: J.Waite, R.Clarke

    OUT: A.Mullett, J.Simpkin

    CROWS
    B: L.Brown, K.Hartigan, J.Lever

    HB: R.Laird, D.Talia, J.Kelly

    C: B.Smith, R.Douglas, R.Sloane

    HF: D.Mackay, T.Walker, T.Lynch

    F: C.Cameron, J.Jenkins, E.Betts

    FOL: S.Jacobs, B.Crouch, M.Crouch

    I/C: C.Hampton, R.Atkins, A.Otten, W.Milera

    EMG: R.Knight, T.Menzel, R.O’Brien

    Unchanged

    Collingwood v Carlton

    Saturday May 6 at the MCG (2.10pm)

    MAGPIES
    B: J.Howe, B.Reid, T.Goldsack

    HB: J.Smith, L.Dunn, B.Maynard

    C: S.Sidebottom, S.Pendlebury, D.Wells

    HF: J.De Goey, D.Moore, W.Hoskin-Elliott

    F: A.Fasolo, M.Cox, J.Elliott

    FOL: B.Grundy, A.Treloar, T.Adams

    I/C: L.Greenwood, T.Phillips, J.Crisp, J.Ramsay

    EMG: J.Blair, J.Aish, T.Broomhead

    IN: B.Reid, J.Ramsay, J.De Goey

    OUT: T.Varcoe, T.Broomhead, H.Schade

    BLUES
    B: S.Docherty, A.Silvagni, L.Plowman

    HB: C.Marchbank, S.Rowe, T.Williamson

    C: K.Simpson, P.Cripps, D.Thomas

    HF: E.Curnow, L.Casboult, N.Graham

    F: M.Wright, J.Weitering, S.Petrevski-Seton

    FOL: M.Kreuzer, B.Gibbs, M.Murphy

    I/C: S.White, C.Curnow, B.Smedts, S.Kerridge

    EMG: L.Jones, D.Cuningham, H.Macreadie

    IN: D.Thomas, S.Kerridge

    OUT: Z.Fisher, J.Silvagni


    Port Adelaide v West Coast

    Saturday May 6 at the Adelaide Oval (4.35pm)

    POWER
    B: D.Byrne-Jones, T.Clurey, J.Hombsch

    HB: M.Broadbent, T.Jonas, J.Pittard

    C: B.Ebert, O.Wines, J.Polec

    HF: T.Boak, A.Young, C.Wingard

    F: S.Gray, C.Dixon, J.Trengove

    FOL: P.Ryder, R.Gray, S.Powell-Pepper

    I/C: H.Hartlett, J.Impey, J.Westhoff, D.Houston

    EMG: K.Amon, L.Austin, A.Johnson

    IN: T.Boak

    OUT: K.Amon

    EAGLES
    B: S.Hurn, T.Barrass, B.Sheppard

    HB: E.Yeo, J.McGovern, S.Butler

    C: A.Gaff, S.Mitchell, C.Masten

    HF: J.Redden, J.Darling, L.Duggan

    F: N.Vardy, J.Kennedy, M.LeCras

    FOL: J.Giles, M.Priddis, L.Shuey

    I/C: D.Sheed, S.Wellingham, J.Hill, K.Mutimer

    EMG: M.Hutchings, F.McInnes, M.Karpany

    Unchanged

    Gold Coast v Geelong

    Saturday May 6 at Metricon Stadium (7.25pm)

    SUNS

    B: K.Kolodjashnij, J.Leslie, J.Joyce

    HB: S.Lemmens, S.May, A.Saad

    C: A.Sexton, G.Ablett, M.Rosa

    HF: J.Lyons, T.Lynch, D.Swallow

    F: B.Matera, P.Wright, J.Martin

    FOL: J.Witts, A.Hall, M.Barlow

    I/C: J.Harbrow, T.Miller, C.Ah Chee, B.Scheer

    EMG: J.Bowes, K.Brooksby, W.Brodie

    IN: S.May, D.Swallow, K.Kolodjashnij, B.Scheer

    OUT: M.Shaw, J.Lonergan, B.Fiorini, J.Bowes

    CATS

    B: A.Mackie, T.Lonergan, Z.Tuohy

    HB: J.Bews, L.Henderson, M.Blicavs

    C: S.Motlop, J.Selwood, J.Murdoch

    HF: D.Lang, H.Taylor, N.Cockatoo

    F: J.Parsons, T.Hawkins, D.Menzel

    FOL: R.Stanley, P.Dangerfield, M.Duncan

    I/C: A.Black, C.Guthrie, G.Horlin-Smith, J.Thurlow

    EMG: S.Menegola, Z.Smith, T.Stewart

    IN: R.Stanley, D.Menzel, J.Thurlow, J.Parsons

    OUT: Z.Smith, T.Stewart, S.Menegola, B.Parfitt

    Western Bulldogs v Richmond

    Saturday May 6 at Etihad Stadium (7.25pm)

    DOGS
    B: M.Boyd, F.Roberts, J.Johannisen

    HB: E.Wood, M.Adams, R.Murphy

    C: L.Hunter, L.Dahlhaus, J.Macrae

    HF: C.Daniel, J.Stringer, C.Smith

    F: L.Jong, Z.Cordy, L.Picken

    FOL: T.Boyd, M.Bontempelli, T.Liberatore

    I/C: M.Suckling, T.McLean, J.Dunkley, B.Williams

    EMG: T.Campbell, L.Webb, B.Dale

    IN: M.Boyd

    OUT: B.Dale

    TIGERS
    B: A.Rance, D.Astbury, D.Grimes

    HB: J.Short, B.Houli, B.Ellis

    C: J.Castagna, J.Caddy, S.Grigg

    HF: D.Rioli, N.Vlastuin, D.Butler

    F: D.Martin, J.Riewoldt, K.McIntosh

    FOL: T.Elton, T.Cotchin, A.Miles

    I/C: K.Lambert, O.Markov, I.Soldo, C.Ellis

    EMG: S.Lloyd, T.Hunt, S.Morris

    IN: A.Miles, T.Elton, C.Ellis, I.Soldo

    OUT: S.Morris, D.Prestia, R.Conca, T.Nankervis

    Sydney v Brisbane

    Sunday May 7 at the SCG (1.10pm)

    SWANS

    B: N.Smith, H.Grundy, J.Lloyd

    HB: H.Marsh, L.Melican, C.Mills 14

    C: I.Heeney, J.Kenned, Z.Jones

    HF: G.Hewett, L.Franklin, T.Papley

    F: W.Hayward, S.Reid, H.Cunningham

    FOL: S.Naismith, D.Hannebery, L.Parker

    I/C from: A.Aliir, O.Florent, J.Foote, N.Newman, J.McVeigh, C.Sinclair, D.Towers

    IN: J.McVeigh, A.Aliir, D.Towers, H.Marsh, J.Foote, S.Naismith, O.Florent

    OUT: J.Laidler, G.Rohan, B.Jack, J.Rose

    LIONS

    B: D.Gardiner, H.Andrews, D.Rich

    HB: S.Mayes, D.McStay, M.Paparone

    C: H.McCluggage, D.Zorko, R.Lester

    HF: L.Taylor, E.Hipwood, J.Barrett

    F: M.Robinson, J.Schache, B.Keays

    FOL: S.Martin, J.Berry, T.Rockliff

    I/C from: R.Harwood, T.Bell, J.Walker, C.Beams, N.Robertson, J.Clayton, M.Close

    IN: J.Walker, M.Paparone, T.Bell, J.Barrett, J.Clayton

    OUT: D.Beams, T.Cutler

    Melbourne v Hawthorn

    Sunday May 7 at the MCG (3.20pm)

    DEMONS
    B: M.Hibberd, T.McDonald, N.Jetta

    HB: J.Hunt, S.Frost, J.Lewis

    C: N.Jones, C.Oliver, T.Bugg

    HF: C.Petracca, J.Watts, M.Hannan

    F: J.Garlett, J.Hogan, J.Kennedy-Harris

    FOL: C.Pedersen, B.Vince, J.Viney

    I/C from: C.Salem, D.Tyson, B.Stretch, D.Kent, A.Neal-Bullen, O.McDonald, J.Wagner

    IN: D.Kent, J.Wagner, J.Hogan, B.Stretch

    OUT: J.Melksham

    HAWKS

    B: G.Birchall, J.Frawley, B.Stratton

    HB: R.Burton, J.Gibson, S.Burgoyne

    C: I.Smith, T.Mitchell, J.O’Meara

    HF: L.Breust, T O’Brien, J.Gunston

    F: P.Puopolo, J.Roughead, C.Rioli

    FOL: B.McEvoy, L.Shiels, L.Hodge

    I/C from: J.Sicily, B.Hartung, B.Whitecross, K.Brand, W.Langford, D.Howe, B.Hardwick

    IN: G.Birchall, C.Rioli, B.Whitecross

    Fremantle v Essendon

    Sunday May 7 at Subiaco (4.40pm)

    DOCKERS

    B: G.Ibbotson, J.Hamling, L.Spurr

    HB: L.Weller, M.Johnson, E.Langdon

    C: H.Crozier, L.Neale, B.Hill

    HF: C.Blakely, S.Kersten, M.Walters

    F: M.Taberner, C.McCarthy, H.Balic

    FOL: A.Sandilands, N.Fyfe, D.Mundy

    I/C from: E.Hughes, G.Logue, D.Tucker, T.Sheridan, B.Grey, N.Suban, C.Sutcliffe

    IN: N.Suban, C.Sutcliffe, M.Taberner

    BOMBERS

    B: M.Dea, M.Hurley, M.Gleeson

    B: M.Baguley, M.Hartley, A.Francis

    C: T.Colyer, B.Goddard, J.Kelly

    HF: O.Fantasia, C.Hooker, D.Zaharakis

    F: A.McDonald-Tipungwuti, J.Daniher, D.Myers

    FOL: M.Leuenberger, Z.Merrett, D.Heppell

    I/C from: D.Parish, J.Green, J.Stewart, K.Mutch, B.Howlett, C.McKenna, B.Stanton

    IN: J.Kelly, B.Stanton, M.Leuenberger, D.Myers, M.Hartley, J.Stewart, A.Francis,

    K.Mutch

    OUT: J.Watson, T.Bellchambers, M.Brown, B.McNiece, A.McGrath
     

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, May 4, 2017.

    1. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Barratt is back and Florent on the extended IC - so hopefully he makes the 22

      (edit) - and newman also on the extended IC - eek !
      Last edited: May 4, 2017
      • Like Like x 4
    2. Penske file
      Penske file
      Interesting selections and non-selections rookiewise. Thinking of off loading Nank , looking seriously at Goldy I know he is up against Jacobs this week, but no Pruess. Nank has made the money Goldy dropped 100K. Is it a risk too far?
      • Dislike Dislike x 5
      • Like Like x 1
    3. The_Swert
      The_Swert
      Three weeks ago I made the reverse trade!
      I just think that Goldy is an ongoing risk with Pruess knocking on the door.
      Nank looks set as a #1 ruck (suspension notwithstanding). Hampson has LTI, Maric can't get a game, Soldo is a promoted rookie.

      My trades this week are for cash generation.
      Roughead > Parsons
      Parfitt > Melican
      • Like Like x 1
    4. Senator96
      Senator96
      Screenshot_2017-05-05-09-38-24.png Theres no escaping the relton roberts nightmare!!
      • Like Like x 7
    5. Senator96
      Senator96
      I dont think that would be a good trade unless youre facing a donut and have to do something. Nankervis is only going to miss a week, park him on the pine until then. Sole ruck for the tigers, scores well apart from last week and can be shifted between ruck and forwards. Even without preuss in the team goldstein didnt score well last week. I am facing a donut as have him in the ruck with no mpp but still wont be trading him out. Looking at turfing roughhead switching nankervis forward and bringing martin in.

      Who to bring in for parfitt this week?

      TU: Parsons
      TD: Black
      • Like Like x 11
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
    6. Waldo666
      Waldo666
      OK everyone here's one for the polls, Beams to......(have $609k to spend)

      :1: Bont
      :2: Dusty + $70k
      :3: Someone else
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 5
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 3
      • Like Like x 1
      • Option 4 Option 4 x 1
    7. brownje
      brownje
      I tried telling myself this year I would not trade out rookies as soon as they get dropped and would give them time to return. I have done this with a few but decided Florent had to go for Fisher a couple of weeks back. Two weeks later Fisher is injured and Florent is back in the side. At least my patience with Barrett has paid off.
      • Like Like x 3
    8. stowie
      stowie
      53 overall? That is wayyy to low
    9. Owen
      Owen
      The rucks are
      Glad I picked Williamson over Fisher even more so now that he has been dropped.
    10. drlok
      drlok
      Have been pretty conservative with trades and seem to have byes under control, although last week put me back on my arse :(
      Current thinking Beams to dePendles (net gain 110K+)
      Now this is where it gets tricky
      TU - Half-fit to Parsons or
      TD - Nank to anyone else preferably a dual position.
      • Like Like x 8
      • Dislike Dislike x 1
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
    11. Penske file
      Penske file
      Currently rucks Sandi/Nank no bench cover, lost that when I covered Gawn with Nank.
      Opt 1// take donut.save trade
      Opt 2// trade Beams move Nank fwd bring in another ruckman
      • Option 2 Option 2 x 9
      • Like Like x 1
      • Dislike Dislike x 1
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
    12. Owen
      Owen
      What ruck do you trade in though? Mummy - you just know he'll get injured and miss at least 3 games somewhere along the line. Grundy - Cox in the team is just ruining his scores. Stef Martin - probably the pick of the bunch this year, but you could wait a week after his crap score last week.
    13. Penske file
      Penske file
      I was thinking of Martin, this has accelerated my post bye plans was waiting on a few rookies to fatten up, but SC gives and it surely takes.
      • Like Like x 2
    14. IPOD
      IPOD
      Only have 580k with the sale of beams can can buy the likes of Gray Dusty Zorko Heppell Priddis or even punt on Oliver or Wines
      Thoughts of which of the above would be the most likely?
      Option 1 Zorko
      Option 2 Gray
      Option 3 Dusty
      Option 4 Priddis
      Option 5 Oliver or Wines
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 6
      • Option 5 Option 5 x 3
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
      • Option 4 Option 4 x 1
    15. traviso
      traviso
      What a cluster of a year. I think i've had 3 sub 2Ks in a row with most of the injuries and poor captain choices. Danger last week, Gawn when he got injured etc.

      So i've got problems everywhere, hawthorn mid pricers, parfitt, eddy, nank, beams, fisher (who i went over balic), simpkin etc. Actually the only ray of light is defence but i don't think anyone managed to screw that up apart from not taking Docherty at the start.

      Looking around though the only coming rookie is Myers a mid and maybe Ayden Johnson. Where as this week we have 2 fwds (Parsons and Black) and 2 Defs (VickersW and Melican). So i'm thinking to go rookie mad

      The question is to
      :1: take the FWDs
      :2: take the BACKs
      :3:one of each
      :4: solve some other problem.
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 4
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
    16. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Newman is an emergency for the Swans - bugger !!!!

      On the flipside - Florent in - yay !!!!!!
      • Like Like x 1
    17. Royboy Forever
      Royboy Forever
      I am holding Nankervis. Will cash out Houston for Balic and put SPP on the field
      • Like Like x 1
    18. benny01
      benny01
      Newman out means I have to trade in a defender or cop a donut. All other lines are fine.
      Stewart, McGrath and Newman out for me.

      Would really love a round 12 or Port GCS Defender however I can also fit round 11 into my side.
      Here's who I could trade in.

      Round 12s of note. Tuohy, McGovern, Rance & Harbrow*

      Round 11s of note. Montagna, Roberton, Lloyd, Jones, Simpson, Johannisen, Hibberd & McDonald.

      As you can see the round 11s are a cut above.

      after all that thinking of going with either Roberton or Lloyd

      TU: Roberton TD: Lloyd
      • Like Like x 3
      • Dislike Dislike x 1
    19. drlok
      drlok
      Newman in!! - Sorry - he was green and he has gone back to orange (and I used 2 ! marks, i'm so ashamed)
      • Like Like x 2

Share This Page