2017 Teams and Round 8 discussion

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, May 11, 2017.

By walesy on May 11, 2017 at 9:43 PM
  1. walesy

    walesy Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2015
    Messages:
    3,177
    Likes Received:
    1,333
    So, international round! A couple of ouchy outs in Treloar and Houston, with the latter being escorted to the slaughter house as I type.

    West Coast Eagles v Western Bulldogs

    Friday May 12 at Subiaco (8.10pm)

    EAGLES



    B: S.Butler, T.Barrass, E.Yeo

    HB: S.Hurn, J.McGovern, B.Sheppard

    C: J.Redden, S.Mitchell, C.Masten

    HF: A.Gaff, J.Darling, M.LeCras

    F: F.McInnes, J.Kennedy, K.Mutimer

    FOL: N.Vardy, M.Priddis, L.Shuey

    I/C: D.Sheed, S.Wellingham, L.Duggan, J.Hill

    EMG: L.Jetta, W.Schofield, M.Hutchings

    IN: F.McInnes, L.Duggan

    OUT: J.Giles, M.Hutchings

    DOGS



    B: M.Boyd, M.Adams, J.Johannisen

    HB: E.Wood, F.Roberts, B.Williams

    C: L.Hunter, L.Dahlhaus, J.Macrae

    HF: C.Daniel, Z.Cordy, C.Smith

    F: L.Jong, J.Redpath, L.Picken

    FOL: T.Boyd, M.Bontempelli, T.Liberatore

    I/C: M.Suckling, T.McLean, L.Webb, B.Dale

    EMG: M.Wallis, M.Honeychurch, D.Hamilton

    IN: J.Redpath, L.Webb, B.Dale

    OUT: R.Murphy, J.Stringer, J.Dunkley

    Hawthorn v Brisbane Lions

    Saturday May 13 at the University of Tasmania Stadium (1.45pm)

    HAWKS



    B: B.Hardwick, J.Frawley, B.Stratton

    HB: R.Burton, J.Gibson, L.Hodge

    C: I.Smith, T.Mitchell, B.Hartung

    HF: L.Breust, T.O’Brien, J.Gunston

    F: P.Puopolo, J.Roughead, C.Rioli

    FOL: B.McEvoy, L.Shiels, S.Burgoyne

    I/C: J.Fitzpatrick, D.Howe, W.Langford, R.Henderson

    EMG: J.Sicily, K.Brand, K.Stewart

    IN: J.Fitzpatrick, R.Henderson

    OUT: G.Birchall, J.Sicily

    LIONS



    B: D.Gardiner, H.Andrews, D.Rich

    HB: S.Mayes, J.Walker, N.Robertson

    C: M.Paparone, D.Zorko, R.Lester

    HF: L.Taylor, E.Hipwood, J.Barrett

    F: T.Bell, J.Schache, M.Close

    FOL: S.Martin, J.Berry, T.Rockliff

    I/C: B.Keays, R.Harwood, R.Bewick, C.Beams

    EMG: J.Clayton, J.Allison, A.Smith

    IN: R.Bewick, J.Walker, T.Bell

    OUT: M.Robinson, D.McStay, H.McCluggage

    St Kilda v Carlton

    Saturday May 13 at Etihad Stadium (2.10pm)

    SAINTS



    B: J.Geary, N.Brown, J.Webster

    HB: J.Newnes, J.Carlisle, D.Roberton

    C: J.Billings, J.Steele, L.Montagna

    HF: J.Gresham, N.Riewoldt, M.Weller

    F: T.Membrey, J.Bruce, J.Sinclair

    FOL: B.Longer, S.Ross, J.Steven

    I/C: L.Dunstan, B.Acres, S.Gilbert, D.Minchington

    EMG: P.McCartin, N.Wright, D.McKenzie

    IN: M.Weller, L.Dunstan

    OUT: K.Stevens, N.Wright

    BLUES



    B: L.Plowman, S.Rowe, A.Silvagni

    HB: K.Simpson, C.Marchbank, T.Williamson

    C: S.Docherty, P.Cripps, M.Wright

    HF: S.Petrevski-Seton, L.Casboult, C.Curnow

    F: E.Curnow, J.Weitering, D.Thomas

    FOL: M.Kreuzer, B.Gibbs, M.Murphy

    I/C: N.Graham, S.White, Z.Fisher, J.Silvagni

    EMG: H.Macreadie, D.Cuningham, B.Boekhorst

    IN: Z.Fisher, J.Silvagni

    OUT: B.Smedts, S.Kerridge

    GWS Giants v Collingwood

    Saturday May 13 at Spotless Stadium (4.35pm)

    GIANTS

    B: Z.Williams, A.Tomlinson, H.Himmelberg

    HB: N.Wilson, P.Davis, T.Scully

    C: S.Reid, S.Coniglio, H.Shaw

    HF: D.Smith, J.Cameron, D.Shiel

    F: S.Johnson, J.Patton, R.Lobb

    FOL: S.Mumford, J.Kelly, C.Ward

    I/C: D.Lloyd, A.Corr, L.Whitfield, T.Taranto

    EMG: M.Kennedy, D.Simpson, H.Perryman

    IN: S.Reid, D.Lloyd, L.Whitfield

    OUT: A.Kennedy, J.Hopper, M.Kennedy

    MAGPIES



    B: J.Howe, H.Schade, T.Goldsack

    HB: J.Smith, L.Dunn, B.Maynard

    C: S.Sidebottom, S.Pendlebury, D.Wells

    HF: J.De Goey, B.Reid, W.Hoskin-Elliott

    F: A.Fasolo, D.Moore, J.Elliott

    FOL: B.Grundy, T.Adams, L.Greenwood

    I/C: J.Blair, J.Aish, T.Phillips, J.Crisp

    EMG: M.Scharenberg, C.Mayne, T.Broomhead

    IN: D.Wells, J.Blair, H.Schade, J.Aish

    OUT: A.Treloar, T.Broomhead, J.Ramsay, M.Cox

    Essendon v Geelong Cats

    Saturday May 13 at the MCG (7.25pm)

    BOMBERS



    B: M.Dea, M.Hurley, C.McKenna

    HB: M.Baguley, M.Hartley, O.Fantasia

    C: B.Goddard, D.Zaharakis, J.Kelly

    HF: J.Stewart, C.Hooker, D.Parish

    F: A.McDonald-Tipungwuti, J.Daniher, J.Watson

    FOL: M.Leuenberger, D.Heppell, T.Colyer

    I/C: A.McGrath, Z.Merrett, J.Green, D.Myers

    EMG: K.Mutch, C.Bird, S.McKernan

    IN: J.Watson, J.Stewart, A.McGrath

    OUT: B.Stanton, M.Gleeson, A.Francis

    CATS



    B: J.Bews, T.Lonergan, T.Stewart

    HB: Z.Tuohy, A.Mackie, J.Kolodjashnij

    C: G.Horlin-Smith, J.Selwood, S.Menegola

    HF: J.Parsons, H.Taylor, M.O’Connor

    F: S.Motlop, T.Hawkins, D.Menzel

    FOL: R.Stanley, P.Dangerfield, M.Duncan

    I/C: M.Blicavs, N.Cockatoo, C.Guthrie, Z.Smith

    EMG: A.Black, J.Murdoch, T.Ruggles

    IN: Z.Smith, T.Stewart, J.Kolodjashnij, M.O’Connor

    OUT: A.Black, J.Thurlow, J.Murdoch, D.Lang

    Adelaide Crows v Melbourne

    Saturday May 13 at the Adelaide Oval (7.40pm)

    CROWS

    B: J.Kelly, D.Talia, L.Brown

    HB: R.Laird, K.Hartigan, D.Mackay

    C: R.Sloane, R.Douglas, B.Smith

    HF: T.Lynch, J.Jenkins, W.Milera

    F: A.Otten, T.Walker, E.Betts

    FOL: S.Jacobs, R.Atkins, M.Crouch

    I/C: B.Crouch, C.Hampton, C.Cameron, T.Menzel

    EMG: J.Gallucci, H.Greenwood, R.O’Brien

    IN: T.Menzel, W.Milera

    OUT: R.Knight, J.Lever

    DEMONS

    B: M.Hibberd, T.McDonald, N.Jetta

    HB: J.Hunt, S.Frost, B.Vince

    C: N.Jones, J.Viney, C.Salem

    HF: C.Petracca, J.Watts, C.Oliver

    F: J.Garlett, J.Hogan, M.Hannan

    FOL: C.Pedersen, J.Lewis, D.Tyson

    I/C: D.Kent, O.McDonald, T.Bugg, J.Wagner

    EMG: B.Stretch, S.Weideman, A.Neal-Bullen

    IN: D.Kent

    OUT: J.Kennedy-Harris

    Richmond v Fremantle

    Sunday May 14 at the MCG (1.10pm)

    TIGERS



    B: A.Rance, D.Astbury, D.Grimes

    HB: J.Short, B.Houli, O.Markov

    C: J.Castagna, J.Caddy, S.Grigg

    HF: D.Rioli, A.Miles, I.Soldo

    F: D.Martin, J.Riewoldt, K.McIntosh

    FOL: T.Nankervis, T.Cotchin, K.Lambert

    I/C FROM: B.Ellis, C.Ellis, D.Butler, T.Elton, B.Lennon, S.Edwards, J.Batchelor

    In: S.Edwards, J.Batchelor, B.Lennon, T.Nankervis

    Out: N.Vlastuin

    DOCKERS



    B: G.Ibbotson, J.Hamling, L.Spurr

    HB: L.Weller, M.Johnson, C.Sutcliffe

    C: E.Langdon, L.Neale, B.Hill

    HF: H.Crozier, M.Taberner, M.Walters

    F: B.Grey, C.McCarthy, S.Kersten

    FOL: A.Sandilands, N.Fyfe, D.Mundy

    I/C FROM: E.Hughes, D.Tucker, C.Blakely, D.Pearce, G.Logue, T.Sheridan, N.Suban

    IN: D.Pearce, N.Suban, T.Sheridan, G.Logue

    OUT: H.Balic

    Gold Coast Suns v Port Adelaide

    Sunday May 14 at Jiangwan Sports Stadium (3.15pm)

    SUNS



    B: J.Joyce, J.Leslie, J.Harbrow

    HB: S.Lemmens, S.May, A.Saad

    C: A.Sexton, G.Ablett, K.Kolodjashnij

    HF: J.Lyons, T.Lynch, T.Miller

    F: B.Matera, P.Wright, J.Martin

    FOL: J.Witts, A.Hall, M.Barlow

    I/C FROM: B.Fiorini, R.Thompson, M.Shaw, J.Bowes, K.Brooksby, B.Scheer, J.Schoenfeld

    IN: R.Thompson, M.Shaw, K.Brooksby, B.Fiorini, J.Bowes, J.Schoenfeld

    OUT: M.Rosa, D.Swallow, C.Ah Chee

    POWER



    B: D.Byrne-Jones, T.Clurey, J.Hombsch

    HB: M.Broadbent, T.Jonas, J.Pittard

    C: B.Ebert, O.Wines, J.Polec

    HF: J.Impey, J.Westhoff, C.Wingard

    F: S.Gray, C.Dixon, J.Trengove

    FOL: P.Ryder, R.Gray, T.Boak

    I/C FROM: S.Powell-Pepper, H.Hartlett, A.Young, K.Amon, A.Johnson, D.Howard, B.Ah Chee

    IN: B.Ah Chee, K.Amon, A.Johnson, D.Howard

    OUT: D.Houston

    North Melbourne v Sydney Swans

    Sunday May 14 at Etihad Stadium (4.40pm)

    KANGAROOS



    B: L.McDonald, R.Tarrant, E.Vickers-Willis

    HB: L.Hansen, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan

    C: S.Gibson, B.Cunnington, S.Atley

    HF: K.Turner, M.Wood, R.Clarke

    F: N.Hrovat, B.Brown, S.Higgins

    FOL: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, T.Dumont

    I/C FROM: M.Williams, J.Anderson, A.Mullett, J.Simpkin, S.Durdin, T.Garner, D.Mountford

    IN: A.Mullett, T.Garner, S.Durdin, J.Simpkin, D.Mountford

    OUT: J.Waite, C.Wagner

    SWANS



    B: N.Smith, H.Grundy, J.Lloyd

    HB: J.McVeigh, L.Melican, C.Mills

    C: I.Heeney, J.Kennedy, Z.Jones

    HF: H.Cunningham, S.Reid, G.Hewett

    F: D.Towers, L.Franklin, T.Papley

    FOL: S.Naismith, L.Parker, D.Hannebery

    I/C FROM: O.Florent, W.Hayward, H.Marsh, N.Newman, G.Rohan, C.Sinclair, K.Tippett

    IN: K.Tippett, G.Rohan, N.Newman

    OUT: Nil
     
    • Like Like x 2

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, May 11, 2017.

    1. bunza52
      bunza52
      What are people thinking of doing with Ottens and Hampton with their high BE? Im thinking a one up one down, but not sure on the down.
      Option 1 - hold and hope they get close to their BE.
      Option 2 - throw the SC rule book out the window and cash in with O'Connor (or McNeice)
      Opt 3 - Berry - would think he will play a few more games considering he just resigned
      Opt 4 - EVW
      Opt 5 - Melican
      • Option 5 Option 5 x 4
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 2
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
      • Option 2 Option 2 x 1
    2. stripey
      stripey
      I'd probably hold otten at this point if I had him... one less trade to make... Hampton on the other hand....
      • Like Like x 2
    3. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Mcniece is not in the bombers 25
    4. anthak
      anthak
      have you got any way to move a mid to def. Im trading out both of them crows rooks and bringing in Myers in the mids. not many decent rookies around this week.
    5. The_Swert
      The_Swert
      My trades this week

      Hampton to M Murphy (Adams goes from Mid to Back)
      Houston to Myers (Pickett goes from Mid to Fwd)

      Holding Beams, Swallow, Otten and Butler.
      • Like Like x 2
    6. Grizzles
      Grizzles
      What do we make of beams? Do they rest him until after his bye? I could turn him into Yeo, Rocky or the bont? I could also hold him along with Treloar. 1 trade so far for me turning hampton into myers a week early to save a nut and not lose cash. Hate going early but it seems to fix 2 birds with 1 stone.
      • Like Like x 2
    7. bunza52
      bunza52
      Yeah, I realise he is not in, but I would expect him back in the near future. He was 'rested' for the Freo game (and didnt play VFL), so I was expecting him to be back this week. I see him named in the VFL for this weeks games. I also thought he play well against the Pies and Dees, (disclaimer) being a Dons supporter, I would like to see him back soon & I'm hope Woosa has similar thoughts!

      Unfortunately I currently dont have a D/M, so would need to move on Beams to do something like this. Really hoping Myers can get his body right, as I think he a lot to offer & at 27, time is ticking...
    8. Penske file
      Penske file
      Every pre-conceived trade I have on Monday goes out of the window on Thursday when the selections drop. I've been trying to off load Hampton for a few weeks, I don't want to jump to Mcniece without at least a tad of surety and Myers needs at least another week. Patience is the name of the game at the moment.
      • Like Like x 3
    9. stowie
      stowie
      Any takers on Mutimer? I haven't watched West Coast lately but he is about to play his 3rd game.
      • Dislike Dislike x 4
      • Like Like x 1
    10. kram
      kram
      I've gone Mutimer, there's not really another option unless you are happy to pay more for Berry or jump the gun on Myers. That was for Houston, which him going out was a no brainer.

      Where it got tricky was who to upgrade. Hampton seems the one who needs to be cut break even wise, but I don't have the dollars to get to Adams. Is Jake Lloyd the poor mans Taylor Adams? Can he keep his scoring average above 100? The alternative is to trade Hoskin-Elliott, who's not scoring too bad, to Heeney. Thoughts?

      Thumbs up - Get Lloyd
      Thumbs down - Get Heeney

      I guess another alternative is to hold the cash til the Powell-Pepper trade is done next week and get Sloane or similar
      • Like Like x 3
      • Dislike Dislike x 1
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
    11. brownje
      brownje
      What are peoples thoughts on Treloar? I cant find much informaiton about his injury, Bucks seems to be remaining tight lipped.
    12. choppers
      choppers
      Some in the media are saying his groin troubles have re-surfaced and he's been playing with the problem for the past few weeks, hence his lower scoring.
    13. brownje
      brownje
      Ive heard this and thats why I am concerned. It was reported as an ankle injury, but why the secrecy? I dont want to knee-jerk trade him, but with Beams already out the pressure is on.
    14. chibbingus
      chibbingus
      Tough call... I'd personally be holding if I can afford to and upgrading someone on the cusp if you have a little extra cash... depends on whether you're chasing league or ranking.
    15. pollypies
      pollypies
      @ Bunza 52 - I'm getting rid of Hampton but keeping Otten. Otten tends to get thrown round the ground a bit to plug holes so his scores can vary depending on the role he plays. Hampton on the other hand has probably peaked.
    16. pollypies
      pollypies
      Does anyone remember when Beams was at Collingwood and he had a two week injury that ended up being the whole season? And there was a lot of secrecy then too. I don't trust the clubs. I don't understand why it is such a big deal to be transparent. I don't trust Beam's injury history either. Keep him at your peril!
      • Like Like x 2
    17. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Soldo out for the Tiges, Sam Lloyd into the 25
    18. stowie
      stowie
      Garner (sore) and Mullett (hand) have withdrawn from North Melbourne's extended squad to face Sydney. Swallow and Preuss included.

    19. stowie
      stowie
      Hogan out, Weideman in

Share This Page