2018 AFL Round 3 Teams and Discussion

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, Apr 5, 2018.

By walesy on Apr 5, 2018 at 11:23 PM
  1. walesy

    walesy Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2015
    Messages:
    3,412
    Likes Received:
    1,653
    Not much movement at all in the teamsheet, which is kinda nice :D

    In: Krooooooze, Higgins
    Out: O'Shea

    ROUND 3 TEAMS (ALL TIMES AEST)

    CARLTON v COLLINGWOOD

    Friday 6 April at the MCG (7.50pm)

    BLUES

    B: Plowman, Jones, Weitering

    HB: Simpson, Marchbank, Mullett

    C: Curnow, Cripps, Murphy

    HF: Garlett, Curnow, Polson

    F: Wright, Casboult, Petrevski-Seton

    FOLL: Kreuzer, Fisher, Kennedy

    I/C: Dow, Cuningham, Thomas, Lamb

    EMG: Kerridge, Graham, Silvagni, McKay

    IN: Kreuzer, Kennedy

    OUT: O’Shea, Byrne

    MAGPIES

    B: Murray, Dunn, Maynard

    HB: Langdon, Scharenberg, Howe

    C: Sidebottom, Pendlebury, Phillips

    HF: Thomas, Reid, Hoskin-Elliott

    F: Stephenson, Cox, Brown

    FOLL: Grundy, Treloar, Adams

    I/C: Crisp, Varcoe, Crocker, Aish

    EMG: Fasolo, Blair, Mayne, Mihocek

    IN: Reid, Cox

    OUT: Moore, Broomhead

    PORT ADELAIDE v BRISBANE LIONS

    Saturday 7 April at the Adelaide Oval (1.45pm)

    POWER

    B: Bonner, Jonas, Houston

    HB: Byrne-Jones, Clurey, Hartlett

    C: Motlop, Wines, Polec

    HF: Boak, Watts, Wingard

    F: Westhoff, Dixon, Rockliff

    FOLL: Howard, Ebert, Gray

    I/C: Gray, Barry, Powell-Pepper, Marshall

    EMG: Amon, Johnson, McKenzie, Thomas

    No changes

    LIONS

    B: Mayes, Walker, Gardiner

    HB: Hodge, Andrews, Witherden

    C: Taylor, Zorko, Bewick

    HF: Rayner, Lester, McCluggage

    F: Christensen, Hipwood, Cameron

    FOLL: Martin, Berry, Beams

    I/C: Robinson, Robertson, Cox, Mathieson

    EMG: McStay, Cutler, Bailey, McInerney

    IN: Robinson

    OUT: McStay

    MELBOURNE v NORTH MELBOURNE

    Saturday 7 April at the MCG (2.10pm)

    DEMONS

    B: Lever, O.McDonald, Wagner

    HB: Vince, Hibberd, Jetta

    C: Lewis, Jones, Salem

    HF: Melksham, Frost, Neal-Bullen

    F: Petracca, Hogan, Garlett

    FOLL: Gawn, Oliver, Tyson

    I/C: Harmes, Kent, Fritsch, Bugg

    EMG: Hannan, Maynard, Pedersen, Hunt

    IN: Frost, Kent

    OUT: Hunt, Pedersen (omitted)

    KANGAROOS

    B: Williams, Thompson, Clarke

    HB: Macmillan, Tarrant, Vickers-Willis

    C: Jacobs, Simpkin, Hartung

    HF: Atley, Waite, Turner

    F: Ziebell, Brown, McDonald

    FOLL: Goldstein, Higgins, Cunnington

    I/C: Anderson, Dumont, Hrovat, Davies-Uniacke

    EMG: Daw, Hibberd, Wood, Zurhaar

    No changes

    GOLD COAST SUNS v FREMANTLE

    Saturday 7 April at Optus Stadium (4.35pm)

    SUNS

    B: Harbrow, Thompson, Joyce

    HB: Rischitelli, May, Kolodjashnij

    C: Weller, Lyons, Fiorini

    HF: Martin, Lynch, Young

    F: Ainsworth, Day, Sexton

    FOLL: Witts, Miller, Swallow

    I/C: Holman, Hanley, MacPherson, Hall

    EMG: Brodie, Crossley, Rosa, Heron

    IN: Hanley

    OUT: Bowes

    DOCKERS

    B: Wilson, Johnson, Ryan

    HB: Sheridan, Pearce, Hamling

    C: Langdon, Neale, Hill

    HF: Cerra, Crowden, Ballantyne

    F: Banfield, Taberner, Matera

    FOLL: Sandilands, Fyfe, Mundy

    I/C: Blakely, McCarthy, Brayshaw, Walters

    EMG: Darcy, Tucker, Cox, Duman

    IN: Sheridan

    OUT: Hill

    SYDNEY SWANS v GWS GIANTS

    Saturday 7 April at the SCG (7.25pm)

    SWANS

    B: Lloyd, Grundy, Smith

    HB: Mills, Melican, Rampe

    C: Heeney, Parker, Rohan

    HF: Hewett, Franklin, Cunningham

    F: Jack, Reid, Towers

    FOLL: Sinclair, Kennedy, Hannebery

    I/C: Florent, Hayward, McVeigh, Papley

    EMG: Foote, Fox, Newman, O’Riordan

    IN: Reid

    OUT: Fox

    GIANTS

    B: Tomlinson, Davis, Shaw

    HB: Haynes, Finlayson, de Boer

    C: Reid, Ward, Whitfield

    HF: Lloyd, Patton, Cameron

    F: Taranto, Himmelberg, Deledio

    FOLL: Lobb, Kelly, Shiel

    I/C: Perryman, Hopper, Coniglio, Corr

    EMG: Bonar, Simpson, Shipley, Keeffe

    IN: Perryman, Hopper

    OUT: Scully, Langdon

    ST KILDA v ADELAIDE CROWS

    Saturday 7 April at Etihad Stadium (7.25pm)

    SAINTS

    B: Geary, Brown, Roberton

    HB: Webster, Carlisle, Savage

    C: Sinclair, Armitage, Newnes

    HF: Acres, Bruce, Billings

    F: Gresham, Membrey, Long

    FOLL: Marshall, Ross, Steven

    I/C: Dunstan, White, McCartin, Coffield

    EMG: Clark, Gilbert, Stevens, Wright

    IN: Marshall, Dunstan, White, Coffield

    OUT: Stevens, Longer, Steele, Clark

    CROWS

    B: Doedee, Talia, Brown

    HB: Laird, Hartigan, Milera

    C: Mackay, Gibbs, Seedsman

    HF: Atkins, Walker, Lynch

    F: Betts, Jenkins, Murphy

    FOLL: Jacobs, Sloane, Douglas

    I/C: Greenwood, Kelly, Ellis-Yolmen, McGovern

    EMG: Hampton, Wilson, Fogarty, O’Brien

    RICHMOND v HAWTHORN

    Sunday 8 April at the MCG (1.10pm)

    TIGERS

    B: Rance, Astbury, Grimes

    HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Short

    C: Grigg, Cotchin, McIntosh

    HF: Castagna, Prestia, Townsend

    F: Riewoldt, Edwards, Butler

    FOLL: Nankervis, Lambert, Martin

    I/C from: Ellis, Graham, Higgins, Menadue, Garthwaite, Lloyd, Conca, Chol

    IN: Vlastuin, Prestia, Higgins, Menadue, Lloyd, Chol, Garthwaite

    OUT: Caddy, Bolton, Ellis

    HAWKS

    B: Brand, Frawley, Hardwick

    HB: Burton, O’Brien, Stratton

    C: Henderson, O’Meara, Smith

    HF: Breust, Gunston, Impey

    F: Puopolo, Roughead, Rioli

    FOLL: McEvoy, Mitchell, Shiels

    I/C from: Mirra, Glass, Pittonet, O’Rourke, Langford, Duryea, Howe, Morrison

    IN: Frawley, Mirra, Glass, Pittonet, O’Rourke, Morrison, Langford

    OUT: Sicily, Schoenmakers, Burgoyne

    WESTERN BULLDOGS v ESSENDON

    Sunday 8 April at Etihad Stadium (3.20pm)

    DOGS

    B: Cordy, Naughton, Williams

    HB: Suckling, Wood, Hunter

    HF: Johannisen, Bontempelli, Jong

    F: Dickson, Redpath, Gowers

    FOLL: English, McLean, Macrae

    I/C (from): Wallis, Boyd, Roberts, Webb, Daniel, Richards, Honeychurch, Biggs

    IN: Dickson, Redpath, Wallis, Boyd, Roberts, Biggs

    OUT: Trengove (injured), Roughead (injured)

    BOMBERS

    B: Dea, Hurley, Saad

    HB: Goddard, Brown, McKenna

    C: Heppell, Stringer, McGrath

    HF: Parish, Hooker, McDonald-Tipungwuti

    F: Merrett, Daniher, Stewart

    FOLL: Bellchambers, Zaharakis, Smith

    I/C (from): Green, Fantasia, Myers, Baguley, Begley, Hartley, McKernan, Langford

    IN: Fantasia, Myers, Baguley, McKernan

    OUT: Nil

    WEST COAST EAGLES v GEELONG CATS

    Sunday 8 April at Optus Stadium (4.40pm)

    EAGLES

    B: Sheppard, Barrass, Hurn

    HB: Duggan, McGovern, Nelson

    C: Masten, Yeo, Cripps

    HF: Redden, Waterman, Ryan

    F: LeCras, Darling, Lycett

    FOLL: Naitanui, Shuey, Gaff

    I/C from: Sheed, Venables, Jetta, Cole, Schofield, Ainsworth, Hutchings, Rioli

    IN: Cole, Ainsworth, Schofield, Hutchings

    OUT: Nil

    CATS

    B: Henry, Kolodjashnij, Stewart

    HB: Tuohy, Blicavs, Bews

    C: Guthrie, Selwood, Menegola

    HF: Gregson, Ratugolea, Parfitt

    F: Parsons, Hawkins, Menzel

    FOLL: Stanley, Dangerfield, Ablett

    I/C from: Cockatoo, Cunico, Fogarty, Guthrie, Selwood, Kelly, Murdoch, O’Connor

    IN: Ratugolea, Cunico, Murdoch, Selwood

    OUT: Nil
     
    • Like Like x 1

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, Apr 5, 2018.

    1. anthak
      anthak
      I’m glad Darcy Fogarty has been dropped. I was leaning towards trading him out already, but was torn between him and Keefe... now it’s an easier decision. DFog will now become Liam Ryan for me. I was tossing up between the two of them preseason and made the wrong choice.

      I’m also trading out Matt Crouch, at this stage for Bonner. I might take a bit of a hit this week, but hopefully not too much, and I’ll have $390k to play with next week!
      • Like Like x 1
    2. Penske file
      Penske file
      Well, Hibberd didn't makes any decisions for me by getting dropped, so I guess he stays. Biting the bullet I'm, about to take.
      • Like Like x 2
    3. RPritch
      RPritch
      Do I hold or trade Darcy Fogarty?
      If I trade him I could get L.Fogarty, Waterman, English, L.Murphy, Gowers or Venables.
      Thumbs up for hold, thumbs down for trade. Comments are appreciated, particularly for which option to trade in if you think I should trade
    4. The_Swert
      The_Swert
      Only one trade.
      Rioli out, Ryan in.

      Although I expect Rioli to rebound. He's too good a player to average 55.
      Last edited: Apr 6, 2018
    5. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      English is the closest to a must have rookie from that list and the other Fogarty is an ok mid rookie if you have the other top guys there. If DF is your only concern then I'd make a trade to either of them.
      • Like Like x 1
    6. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      I'll canvas the community too. Three trade options this week:
      A - Naughton to Bonner
      B - Cameron to English
      C - ZGL to Ryan

      I should do trades...
      :1: A & B
      :2: A & C
      :3: B & C
      :thumbsd: Other (please comment)
      • Option 2 Option 2 x 6
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 2
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 2
    7. Iain
      Iain
      I have the exact same issues with my rookies P_L, plus Mills, Bont and Zerrett.

      So far I'm thinking of leaving the rookies alone and going Bont to Cogs and Mills to Simpson but it seems pretty extravagant for this stage of the season really.

      Thumbs up: go for it
      Thumbs down: hold trades
      Option 1: trade some rookies instead
      • Like Like x 3
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 1
    8. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      Yeah probably do the Conigilio trade. Then use the other one on a rookie?
      • Like Like x 1
    9. warsaken
      warsaken
      One for the thumbs

      :thumbsu: - Venables
      :thumbsd: - Waterman

      Who will stay in WCE team longer???
      • Like Like x 8
    10. Iain
      Iain
      Thanks mate, I just don't have any rookies that I really like, ZGL is the most tempting to move since he'll miss a month but I just can't seem to justify a sideways rookie trade for 4 weeks when I'm already behind the 8-ball. I think if anything I'd rather move Mills on than Bont so might just do Mills to Simpson and see how I feel about it all tomorrow. Bloody SC already doing my head in.

      Thanks everyone else for the thumbs too :thumbsu:
      • Like Like x 1
    11. RPritch
      RPritch
      Thanks for the feedback. With O'Connor being an out this week I am now considering two trades. I have O'Connor, Naughton and DF in my team (at least the other 27 are all great, except Bont who's ordinary) and I have several options:
      :1: Fogarty and O'Connor out for English and Murphy
      :2: Fogarty and Naughton out for Marshall/English and Murphy
      :3: Fogarty out for English
      :4: Naughton/O'Connor out for Murphy
      :5: Hold trades
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 5
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 3
    12. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      Fair enough. Kade is probably the #1 upgrade target in defense as it is right now anyway. I think prem sideways are worse to do than rookie one, but does depend on your teams issues.

      Thanks to everyone on their input too.

      What do we think about captaincy choices this week? Really bad with Richmond, Geelong and Hawthorn all playing on Sunday. Gawn or Fyfe for VC?
    13. anthak
      anthak
      I’m going with Fyfe for VC
      • Like Like x 3
    14. stripey
      stripey
      I seem to have killed my SC app... I have 7 defenders on the ground and only one on the bench o_O
      • Like Like x 1
    15. FunkSoulBrother
      FunkSoulBrother
      Ok...So I flicked Naughton for Murphy despite my concern over Murphy's job security. I just couldn't see the value in holding Naughton (most likely will ton up now...so feel free to jump on!)

      My next pressing decision is whether to flick Giles-Langon for Ryan - price for price straight swap but although Ryan will give the price rise, he will likely be hot & cold and also potential ??? on his job security.

      I have already had 3 correctional trades and 4 is getting up there. Just feel that this is a tough choice and whichever way I choose it's bound to be the wrong choice...either could be a spectacular back fire.

      I could also look at English but not entirely convinced on him and he wont help me through the byes as I have Natanui with Olongo on the R Bench for loophole purposes

      The third option is to upgrade to say Christenson, who I was seriously considering preseason

      Basically, I have all the other "must have" rookies. So I will be making money anyway. Decisions.. Decisions!!

      :1: Ryan
      :2: English
      :3: Christenson
      :4: hold fire and sit on Giles-Langdon
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 2
    16. stripey
      stripey
      I’m holding onto Langdon myself as I already have all the must have rookies and don’t like the others on offer with low breakevens (waterman/Gowers/Venables)... there is no guarantee he will go straight back into the side which if he plays a couple of reserves games turns it into a 6 week absence... if that’s the case you will wish you traded...

      I don’t think there is any trouble with Ryan’s JS but agree his scores will go up and down.. perhaps wait a week and see how Higgins goes on debut... he will be a trade down target in a couple of weeks assuming he goes well (defers cash generation tho)
    17. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Final teams for #AFLPowerLions:

      Dayne Beams is a late out for the Lions, replaced by Tom Cutler.
      No changes for Port Adelaide.
    18. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Final teams for #AFLDeesNorth:

      Robbie Tarrant (hamstring) has been replaced by Majak Daw.
      No changes for Melbourne
    19. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      Chose the wrong one. Fyfe on a massive score. Normally play it safe but will role dice on Dusty doing better than Gawns 115.

Share This Page