Broughton vs Enright

Broughton and Enright
-Pretty much the same price around the 480k Premium bracket
-Both have a Bye during the Round 6 Multi-Bye

So which one will score more this year?

I'm personally leaning towards starting Broughton and possibly picking up Enright later?

Can you separate the two ?

 

At the risk of confusing the issue, I had both in my first draft squad, and then cut both. I found that I was too exposed to the Rd6 multibye. There's a reasonable chance that I will have both before the season is done.

If choosing one over the other, I would also start with Broughton.

 

I have had Enright for the last few years but saw some signs during the last half of the season that teams were working him out and cutting down his scores.
I have gone Broughton instead this year.
Most of the Cats I am not sure about so I am leaving most out and making them my upgrade targets if they smash it early on.
I suspect Bartel will kill them this year but don't want to risk it so he is my first upgrade target along with Ablett.

 

Im with adeelite.
Enright has served me well over recent years, however this year I don't believe that he will be able to kepp his price.

Broughton on the other hand, always has the injury risk above him, but nearly a guaranteed 90+ every week if he stays on the field (hopefully he does).

Broughton is in my current team and I believe he will stay.

 

Add another poster to the list as well

A bit of a 'changing of the guard' this year. Enright has been a great servant, but Broughton/Duffield gets his spot this year in my team.

It was hard to fault his performance this afternoon however, he still looked pretty decent. If he can have a decent game against the Saints where he might cop the dreaded defensive forward tag then he could well come back into consideration.

I do enjoy Broughtons' consistency however. Very much like a Mark Murphy in the backline, albeit 10 or so points less.

 

I have gone for Broughton, too. Some of Enright's scores last year were terrible and who knows what role Scott has him pencilled in for. Plus he is another Geelong player and I have enough of them already! Duffield is tempting too and may be a good POD......

 

No brainer also - Broughton all the way.

Enright: older (bad way), new gameplan of cats means possible less possession footy

Broughton: older (good way), move in midfield, 3rd year, impressed in NAB thus far.

That said hats off to Enright, has been a wonderful DT/SC player over the last few years. Just think there are way better options this year. Would also go with the Duffman before Enright.

 

Damn here's me thinking (hoping) Greggy would be avoided by the mass's!

 

I have to thank Enright for his service to my SC team over the years but now it's time to part ways and bring in Broughton

 

Enright has been a lock in my team for past few years. I'd even say he was my first picked every start of the year.

Amazing how far Broughton has come from few years ago when he was THE bargain to now considered a possible LOCK!

Anyhow ... i want to throw one more name out into the ring: Malceski. He's priced bit cheaper than Broughton/Enright and (supposedly) had an amazing pre-season.

THoughts?

 

Lucas,

How about Duffield, Grimes and Shaw?

Nice POD with Grimes the only one injury prone.

 

Why none of the above Lucas? Three proven guns, true they have injury and shut-down concerns, but who around the price do you like more?

 

have Broughton, is there room for him and Duffy in the same backline

 

@Lucas, isn't supercoach the best contraception.....

Another option I'm thinking about guys is going hard with richmond players....Conners,Lids(offcourse) and Newman....Conners for his run in the midfield and Newman for his kicks. Also Late bye......

 

Yeah true, Broughton and Grimes are probably the way to go.

 

I don't have any of them either, I'm on Duff Beer