Chapman or Selwood?

What are you guys thoughts on who would be the better option out of Chappy or Selwood - to bring in next week?
I'm feeling that Chappy would be a higher scorer and has MPP as an advantage, but there is the question over his durability. Selwood is staedy in this regard...
Thoughts???

 

Chappy if you are upgrading in the forwards, and Selwood if you are upgrading into the mids.

 

Neither if you didnt start with them Cats have bye round 23 and pies round 24 if going for leagues

 

Correction Fez:

Cats BYE = R22
Bombers BYE = R24

I agree with Liquid Six, Burly. I'm looking to bring Chapman in next week to complete my forward line - hopefully Krakouer plays or Tapscott goes up enough this week to just make the upgrade.

I've had Selwood since R1.

 

Think Fez meant Cats are playing Pies in round 24...

 

Moonwalker i meant playing the Pies round 24 and sorry bye was out by a week still during the finals

 

Yeah, all good Fez.

Either way I'd still look to get in some Cats players Burly. Depending if you make the league top-4 and win the first round you will miss the Cat's R22 bye. Most teams would have Swan/Pendlebury and at least one Cats player so you won't be that much disadvantaged come the GF if you make it.

 

I've got enough funds to go Tapscott - Chapman if I wish to complete my forward line. I just realise that Selwood is pretty good value atm.

Would it be overkill to get both considering I'm aiming at league win and R22 bye, R24 Pies should be considered?