Personaly I can't split Darley/Bugg/Tomilson all have there pros and cons, but all 3 definitly ahead of Townsend and Mohr. I think I'll wait for SC scores to be released before picking which 2 out of the 3 make the cut.
Cunningham from Sydney word is he will get a fair bit of game time early he has been training the house down.
You guys reckon it'll be better to have Adam Kennedy or Anthony Miles in the midfield bench? Adam Kennedy has a forward link which will be helpful since I have no links there and he has been named in the round 1 team. I feel like Miles might be the better player, however, he doesn't have mpp ability and isn't named in the round 1 team.
<blockquote>Quote from teraferma on March 23, 2012, 17:02 Cunningham from Sydney word is he will get a fair bit of game time early he has been training the house down. </blockquote> Handy player but not top of the list for S/C mid rookies. Shakey JS and a bloke that'll kick a couple of goals but not do a huge amount imo. Heath is a Mr Snufalupalass and a DO NOT TOUCH stamp on him. If you had to pick a Swanie Rookie then "Richie" is the one but it's a big risk for a not so big reward in my opinion.
[map][/map]<blockquote>Quote from teraferma on March 23, 2012, 17:02 Cunningham from Sydney word is he will get a fair bit of game time early he has been training the house down. </blockquote> Magner, D Smith, C Smith, Shiel, Miles, Ledger, Coniglio, Wingard, Neale, J McDonald Pick your top 5 ?????.
<blockquote>Quote from crew on March 23, 2012, 19:22 [map][/map]<blockquote>Quote from teraferma on March 23, 2012, 17:02 Cunningham from Sydney word is he will get a fair bit of game time early he has been training the house down. </blockquote> Magner, D Smith, C Smith, Shiel, Miles, Ledger, Coniglio, Wingard, Neale, J McDonald Pick your top 5 ?????.</blockquote> Coniglio > Shiel > Miles > D Smith > Magner
What do people think of Cam Guthrie? Not sure how his JS is looking? Solid NAB cup form and i just see him as having higher potential than Clarke from the pies. If someone could help that would be great.
Suggest you read the article series on this site by Bearfly which describes all of the Port players and their various merits/defiencies. If you read this and still want Pfieffer over Ledger, I can't help you.
Seems to be plenty of people who think Ledger will be a regular sub, which may sway people away from him.
Interesting watching the rookies last night and tracking the "good things". It seems that there will be plenty of really good meat in Defense and Mids, Rucks have 3 or 4 solid rookie options, and a few good F/M options. At the moment forward seems to be a bit light on, so starting to think 5 premiums and 4 rookies in the forward line, and only go with 3 premiums and 5 rookies in the middle and 4 and 5 in defense. The cashcows back and middle would appear on first blush to be likely to have the fastest growth potential. Anyone else thinking the same way? Has anyone spotted any decent D/M rookies worth considering?