Which cow to cull?

Hey yall,

So i'm looking to get Pendles in this week but need to decide what cow to butcher.

Old Mac
Sheil
Magner

Thoughts?

 

None of them as they all have alot more value left in them, however if you need to get rid then not McDonald as he has by far the lower break even (still in the negs).

 

do you really need him in this week? If not I'm sure the cows will rise in price more than Pendles would, so you'll effectively get him cheaper next week.

 

@Seabads
I didn't even think of this! Now strongly considering holding off on my trade...even if Pendlebury scores 140+ (he will tonight) i think Shiel will still gain more money than him.

But then you have to consider if Shiel gets the green or red vest?

I have the exact same trade options as DBY.

I currently traded Shiel as Mac has a great BE as mentioned but also as Magnet has a higher ceiling and will play every week barring injury.

Long term and outside of SC world...Shiel would be the player I pick for my team. But for this year he gets the cut.

 

@Seabads
I didn't even think of this! Now strongly considering holding off on my trade...even if Pendlebury scores 140+ (he will tonight) i think Shiel will still gain more money than him.

But then you have to consider if Shiel gets the green or red vest?

I have the exact same trade options as DBY.

I currently traded Shiel as Mac has a great BE as mentioned but also as Magnet has a higher ceiling and will play every week barring injury.

Long term and outside of SC world...Shiel would be the player I pick for my team. But for this year he gets the cut.

 

@dby are you playing for league or overall ? and do you have ablet benched?

 

League, have Ablett benched.

I'm thinking downgrade Fyfe to Adams and spending that cash upgrading one of those mid cows to Pendles.

Seabeads that's a good point but want the win this week.

 

@Seabass
Supercoach is about points not team value.

 

Agree with SC Superstar.

@H_Dons - agree, Shiel is going to be a player. We should get him down to the Dons!

Having said that, he is the cow I am looking to cull next week either for Horsley or Adams. I've got Magnet, Old Mac and Greene in the mids as well, so out of those I think Shiel is the one who will be closest to maxing out