For me it comes down to these players in these areas: DEF: Need to pick 3 out of the 5, Bugg,Ellis,Morris,Smedts and Mohr? MID: Need 1 out of the 2, Horsley or Adams? FWD: need 2 out of the 4, Milera,A.Kennedy,D.Smith and Treloar? Any help much appreciated. Feel free to whack together your own dilemma and i will have a go at answering back!
Bugg, Mohr, Morris/Ellis (Richmond Boys to close to call) Horsley Milera and Treolar Thats my opinion anyway
I agree with Fitzy. The difference between Morris and Ellis shouldn't be significant anyway, so just flip a coin really.
<blockquote>Quote from alex_naumovski on May 11, 2012, 15:49 Def: Bugg, Mohr and Morris/Ellis Mid: Horsley Fwd: Adams(swap with Kennedy), and Smith/Treloar</blockquote> Ahh totally forgot about Adams' mid/fwd link! Thanks for the advice/opinions guys, much appreciated!!!
Bugg (may follow Rischitelli or Swallow = more midfield), Mohr(scored well last week against the lack of key forwards, same story against GC) and Ellis (Getting better each week) Horsley (Mature body, should score nicely against GWS) Smith (Form is good, rectified efficiency problems last week) and Kennedy (played a lock down role on Betts last week, should get more free rein this week against GC) My two cents.
Definately start Bugg, Mohr and Adams (Fwd) IMO. Harder call with the rest. What about - Shiel or Horsely on field?
<blockquote>Quote from AngryAnt on May 11, 2012, 15:52 So the consensus here is Mohr ahead of Ellis and Morris? How about Coniglio v Shiel?</blockquote> I'm going Coniglio.
RE: Shiel vs Coniglio Shiel for mine. Looks more consistent. Coniglio has just the one score over 64, whilst Shiel has four and they are the last four games he has played.
The GWS v GC game will be interesting. Usually both those teams are on the wrong end of a thrashing which results in lower SC scores. Many GC and GWS players may score higher than normal as the pie gets shared more evenly.
@AngryAnt - I'd go Shiel over Coniglio @Guardian_Hawk - I'd go Horsely over Shiel With Horsley a starter in the mids, I've only got one spot left for either Shiel, Magner, D Smith or Kennedy. (Adams is F7) I'm thinking Shiel, cos I reckon he's starting to blossom. Interested in other views though...
Shiel over Coniglio was an expensive 40 point mistake. I hope no one took my advice, haha. Just goes to show what SC can do you.