Ruck upgrade? Help please

Hey guys, looking to upgrade Giles this week but who should I get?
Maric? Nic Nat? Ryder?


My team:

Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Newman, Lake, Dempsey (Darley, Ellis)

Ablett, Selwood, Pendles, Watson, Mitchell, Thompson (Gibson, Couch)

Kruezer, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

Franklin, Dangerfield, Sidebottom, Martin, Goodes, Cloke, Zorko (Kennedy, Hall)

Will be upgrading Lake, Newman, or Dempsey to Carrazzo next week.

Currently have $320k with 8 trades left

 

Hi I've got a similar decision this week - but I already have Nic Nat and Giles is my second ruck.

If you have the cash I would defiantly go Nic Nat or Maric! Cox, Ryder and Jacobs are all good options though.

 

Yeah thinking the same. Was going to go Ryder to save cash but being stingey this year has cost me with the likes of Newman, Dempsey and maybe Cloke so I'm thinking I'll just fork out the cash. Which one out of Nic Nat and Maric though? Both have good draws

 

Maric, he's been the most consistent.

 

I agree with fidelsfinger, I have a feeling when Hille is put back in the side Ryder's average may go down!

 

Thanks for the advice guys