Who would be best to trade in now for league wins? Only clashes I have is Gibbs (if I take Scotland) and Puopulo (if I take Suckling)...and for argument sake I have Selwood and Chappy (if I take Enright). I read somewhere that Scotland would be ideal if going for overall. Correct or no? Also, the Hawks defence has a good run of games (in accordance with the holy grail TICKER). So would Suckling be the way to go?
Adcock for sure. Scotland is a better scorer that Suckling, but Scotland will have bye in the finals. Instead of Scotland what about Fisher, Shaw, Deledio
Plus Adcock has the benefit of running his bye during the multi-bye. That said though, hawthorns style this year is really promoting a butt-load of touches in their backline and only seems to be getting stronger back there.
cleary enright and scotland have the most experience and class, both should be more consistent than adcock and suckling. At enrights price there is no goin past for me, yes his had a couple of bad games but i guarantee he will turn it around and out score adcock and suckling for the year!!
broge I really like what your saying about Enright.. He is a bargin atm, But there is a reason why he is so cheap.... Hope he comes good so i can pick him up
I reckon with the focus on the Hawks' chip and charge, teams will just employ a harsher forward press. I can understand their 'rope a dope' tactics and it's seemed to work vs St Kilda and Port, but Geelong just ploughed right through it, and I can see other top teams doing the same unless the Hawks change tack. Will be really interested to see what happens in R14 when the Hawks play the Dons. MCG at night, lots to play for. For mine, Scotland is the one to get, so long as you could say hold Heppell as cover for Round 23.
Thanks for the responses guys. With Enright, I might wait on him to see if he'll come good or if he's doing a "Didak". Scotland is tempting especially with my D/M ability, which I can use come finals time. I only have Gibbs in the back. Suckling is tempting too with Hawthorn's tactics and will give me a nice healthy bank account. But do you think the excellent strength of schedule for the Hawks is good enough to get him? I already have Frankling and Rioli tho.
One thing I do know with Ellis and Bruce outside the Hawks best 22, as well as a few others, if Suckling has any loss of form he's back playing for Box Hill.