I have heard that Hargrave's foot is not quite right but not sure whether Guthrie is up to it. Thumbs Up Guthrie, Thumbs Down Hargrave
<blockquote>Quote from Jason on March 28, 2012, 19:29 There are no thumbs in here mate. I'm of the opinion that Guthrie is up to it.</blockquote> <img src="http://tooserious.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/dlvz0-thumbs_up_bciy.jpg" />
<blockquote>Quote from Smashcollingwood on March 28, 2012, 19:26 I have heard that Hargrave's foot is not quite right but not sure whether Guthrie is up to it. Thumbs Up Guthrie, Thumbs Down Hargrave </blockquote> Where did you hear about Hargreaves foot?
Try this ant: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/relaxed-and-comfortable-20120326-1vurj.html One missed training session is all that has really been reported.
Haven't heard a thing about Guthrie, just that his NAB form was good, and there is a spot in DEF up for grabs. But is there? Sure Milburn retired but he was never permanently in there during his final year anyway, was rested a LOT. JS a massive question. But if he's named on that back flank on Friday afternoon, pick him. I'll be downgrading Dempsey (near identical price to Hargrave) and using using the extra cash to possibly get an elite ruck. Getting more and more worried of my Hale decision by the day...
I like what I saw in Guthrie during NAB cup. If JS was not an issue then I would lock him in, however I have an issue paying such a high price for a rookie with questionable JS. Would like to hear from Cats supporters as to Guthrie's chances of getting game time.
I think Guthrie will get a good chance this year, he should handle it well but it's not guaranteed. There's room to put him in there but I think he may share it a bit with Smedts. Hargrave has far greater js.