OK its time to put something out there for discussion and its a further refinement of a ranking system I devised earlier.  Its still got some tweaks needed, but effectively it rates players on their 2009 efforts, takes into account price and score fluctuations (generally the more consistent the better), uses some durability data from 2008-2009, and tests this against the 2010 price.

Ive tried to keep this system out of my hands as much as possible and let stats do the talking, but in any system there must be bias.  Mine is probably the players overall performance and 2009 (as distinct from 2008) performance.  If you didnt play 2009, too bad.  (It means youre in line for the 2nd year blues!  Haha!).  Note also that I have not taken into account such things as preseason injuries or suspensions leading into the 2010 season.  Effectively these stats could have come out the day the price points were reached for the 2010 SuperCoach year.

To regular watchers of price valuations and the consistent players, the results probably wont shock you much.  I will list the top 20 in overall (out of 1000 points), then the top 5 in each category I rated them on (Scoring Consistency, Price Consistency, Value, Durability and Captaincy Suitability).

[span style="text-decoration: underline">[span style="color: #ff0000">OVERALL
1) JIMMY BARTEL 871
2) Brett Kirk 866
3) Nick Riewoldt 852
4) Chris Judd 851
5) Ryan OKeefe 845
6) Marc Murphy 843
7) Jude Bolton 842
8) Joel Corey 841
9) Brendon Goddard 839
=10) Daniel Cross 837
=10) Joel Selwood 837
12) Luke Power 831
=13) Simon Black 829
=13) Leigh Montagna 829
=13) Corey Enright 829
16) Brett Deledio 827
17) Shane Tuck 826
=18) Dane Swan 824
=18) Cameron Bruce 824
20) Nick Dal Santo 823

Scoring Consistency (/100)
1) Gary Ablett (OA23) 100
2) Leigh Montagna 99
=2) Dane Swan 99
4) Chris Judd 98
=4) Marc Murphy 98

Price Consistency (/100) - (Showing only top 10o players only in this category though other players were part of the top 5 they were largely outlier values such as Mark Jamar from Melbourne.  Top 100 are more useful to look at.)
1) Marc Murphy 84
2) Jordan Lewis 79 (OA 81)
3) Brendon Goddard 78
4) Nathan Bock 76 (OA 54)
=4) Bret Thornton 76 (OA 61)

Value (/100)
1) Jarrad Waite 88 (OA 69)
2) Luke Hodge 87 (OA 47)
3) Wayde Skipper 86 (OA 450)
=4) Shaun Burgoyne 85 (OA 103)
=4) Brett Kirk 85
=4) Matt Maguire 85 (OA 444)
=4) Sean Rusling 85 (OA 451)

Durability (/100)
1) Dane Swan 100
=2) Brett Kirk 99
=2) Luke Power 99
=2) Corey Enright 99
=2) Brett Deledio 99
=2) Marc Murphy 99

Captaincy (/100)
1) Gary Ablett 100
2) Jimmy Bartel 98
=3) Leigh Montagna 97
=3) Ryan OKeefe 97
=3) Adam Goodes 97
=3) Brendon Goddard 97

Other players values on request.