I can see both sides to this discussion and think that MartyG makes a good point. Coaches wouldn’t draft the highest scoring replacement they’d likely take the most promising instead. I drafted an injury prone player in Bennell and think it would be unfair to have a second dip after making such a choice. Hell, I didn’t even take any top up players for Hurley, Ryder & Myers when I had the chance so if it went to a vote I’d likely vote against. Having the right mix of experience and youth is one of the balancing acts we all need to perform.