basically eckie has suggested (warning paraphrasing ahead) posting a BASE Superocoach team then allowing interested coaches to make two changes (if wanted) prior to Round 1 kicking off, then seeing what happens when the impacts of trading start to kick in !
Good work Tassie...the only problem so far is that we would need a FULL league, otherwise we will just get shafted when playing against other teams. If we can get another 14 people interested in this kind of a league, i think it will be a real goer. Anyone else interested in this???
so to be clear the concept is that we all start with the same team and then make trades to our individual team throughout the season as we see fit? if so, an interesting concept. i'll put my hand up to be involved
That's it Liquid. All start with the same team, and then it comes down to who makes the better trades throught out the year.
Hi All, 1 - SOMEONE needs to start up a league so teams can be entered ! 2 - the people that enter need to agree fairly soon thereafter (say Monday/Tuesday) on the basic starting team (with each coach allowed to make 2 changes allowed to the 33 picked) - three alternatives proposed are to base the team on a random autofill, to adopt the TS Donor team (if this is acceptable to the TS Donors of course, don't want to offend anyone) or to have an experinced Supercoacher "play God", but feel free to make anymore suggestions. As a 4th alternative I'll put up a "suggested team" - based on Guns N Rookies - as a separate post as a starting point for anyone/everyone to pick apart. Cheers TTH
i reckon ưe should just go ưith a general côokie cut team. and not be allowd to make any changes beore R1 starts ưe ươnt be able to úse the donor team, as I have promised to kêep that team a secret amongst donors, until the season starts. do ưe still need a couple òf people? I havent counted properly...
Def - GODDARD B MPP , DELEDIO B MPP , BROUGHTON G, ENRIGHT C, GILBEE L MPP , OTTEN A, HIBBERD M MPP , TOY J, PUOPOLO P, DUIGAN N Mid - SWAN D, SWALLOW A, GIBBS B MPP , GAFF A, POLEC J, HEPPELL D MPP , SWALLOW D, PITTARD J, WALLIS M Ruck - SANDILANDS A, MUMFORD S, SMITH Z, MCCAULEY B, , RIEWOLDT N, HARVEY B MPP , BROWN J, RIOLI C Fwd - RIEWOLDT N, HARVEY B MPP , BROWN J, RIOLI C, GIANSIRACUSA D, KRAKOUER A MPP , LAMB J, PRESTIA D MPP , TAPSCOTT L, MICHIE V and $21,700 in cash - as above this is hopefully a more competitive squad than an autofill (which I would find boring) but feel free to criticise or make changes - it would be fairest to all to make sure there isn't any juggling for Wednesday/Thursday night selections as you wouldnt want anyone not able to make changes in time and skewing the concept. - also feel free to suggest anyone who would be willing and able to "play God" and pick a team (by Monday/Tuesday) that would provide some real trading challenges - whether we go "cookie cut" vs "2 changes" - doesn't worry me to much, i think the concern (by eckie - who came up with the concept first on another thread) was that if people choose the same captain/subs/emgs there could be a few identical scores in Round 1/other early rounds - but obviously this can be decided on a majority rules decision