2018 Trade Discussions

As much as I'd hate to veto a trade, I was really close on this too. In the end though, there is only 18 ruckman and if you don't have 1 it's pretty hard to win a flag. For Holky's sake I hope Trengrove gets to the right club.

 

The recent rumour is Trengrove is going to the Bulldogs who already have 3 playing ruckman.

 

My opinion was close to this one, I think it is way over the odds for a player like Trengove but obviously Holky really wanted his player so he went out and got him. I think veto's are more about deliberate dodgy action rather than thinking someone is paying over the odd in a certain trade

 

Vetos are bullshit.

The rule should only be there to protect the league against cheating and collusion.

eg. Dangerfield for a round 3 MSD pick.

Only extreme cases like this should be vetoed.

Everyone rates players differently and has different positional needs within their squads.

Trades that seem weighted heavily to one side at the time they go through can end up working out better for the team on the other side of the deal.

Have a look back over your trades history. I'm sure there would be at least one in there that seemed like you'd pulled off a great trade at the time but it ended up being a stinker.

Each to their own. Build your team and trade anyway you like

 

Holky hope your club medicos have given Mummy the once over! No certainty to be at the Giants in 2018... Will a club take an injury risk on him?

 

AFL Website "The Giants are preparing for life after Shane Mumford, whose career hangs in the balance pending medical advice on his injured foot and degenerative knee."

 

I saw that yesterday as well but didn't say anything. Surely due diligence has been carried out!

 

Season Greetings Coaches
The Bulls are looking to bolster our Def / Fwd stocks
Midfielders Will Hoskin-Elliott and Stephen Hill are players up for negotiation to facilitate this...
Acquire within!