Log in or Sign up

Rate My Team (RMT) 2016 - Mid February Edition

Discussion in 'Blog' started by Jason, Feb 9, 2016.

By Jason on Feb 9, 2016 at 4:23 PM

Jason Moderator Staff Member

Joined:

Jan 3, 2016

Messages:

3,810

Likes Received:

1,418

The TooSerious tradition that is Rate My Team (RMT) is back in 2016!

Let's set the ground rules for RMT, nice and clear.

1. In order to get feedback on your own team, you must first provide feedback on the teams that have been recently posted. This is the golden rule and is what makes this whole thing work.
2. If you just post your team without giving any feedback, your post will be deleted.
3. Please refrain from commenting on teams that have been posted by others that have not followed the golden rule.
4. Keep it civil. Constructive criticism is fine. But there is a line and please don't cross it.

To kick things off, I'll put my current SC team up for discussion.

Find that value, search hard and follow your instincts!
Or just tell me I'm dreaming and where I've gone wrong...

Last edited: Feb 9, 2016

Jason, Feb 9, 2016

#1

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by Jason, Feb 9, 2016.

Local Comments

Tags:
- rmt
- supercoach
Page 6 of 8
< Prev 1 ← 3 4 5 6 7 → 8 Next >
1. That KI Guy
  
  Len said: ↑
  
  Subject to fitness looks a good side, I'm with walesy on Simpson, Yeo is who I'd swap him for.
  Click to expand...
  
  Yeah I'm firming on Yeo now with Masten out and Sheed not 100%.
  Still like Simpson in there too though. Really want eski but think risk is too much if I take Libba and wells too.
  
  That KI Guy, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #101
2. Len
  
  That KI Guy said: ↑
  
  Yeah I'm firming on Yeo now with Masten out and Sheed not 100%.
  Still like Simpson in there too though. Really want eski but think risk is too much if I take Libba and wells too.
  Click to expand...
  
  It's much easier to justify some of the mid-pricers this year, but for me it doesn't make them that much less risky, I have two at moment if you include Anderson, three will be my max, I hope..
  
  Len, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #102
3. Owen
  
  Len said: ↑
  
  It's much easier to justify some of the mid-pricers this year, but for me it doesn't make them that much less risky, I have two at moment if you include Anderson, three will be my max, I hope..
  Click to expand...
  
  I think the mid pricers up forward and down back are more easily justified as (in my eyes) the top 10 averaging players at the end of year for forward and defence are much less set in stone than previous years. This is likely due to more DPP's being forced to be mid only? And then you look at Libba, Crouch, O'Meara and they look like bargains and potential keepers as M7, M8, M9. As much as I want a GNR I keep finding places for some mid pricers.
  Like x 1
  Owen, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #103
4. Grizzles
  
  Here is my current team!
  A lot to spend in the rucks but I think it should equate to at least a 50pt advantage over most teams. They both ruck solo for their respective teams and are both very durable.
  Parker under priced by a fair amount in my eyes due to his injuries and would love to squeeze Wines in for the same reason. Think bother will average 110+ this year.
  I like Bennel over Barlow for supercoach. Hopefully his calf is alright but I think that Lyon won't take any of his crap and hopefully he pushes his average north by another 5+.
  
  What do the great minds think?
  
  Grizzles, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #104
5. Ratmata
  
  Spirio43 said: ↑
  
  Hey Ratmata
  
  I like the rance and simpson picks.. been speaking to a couple of the boys who watch carlton training and been saying he is tearing it up (still only preaseason, will see more tonight). However, i think you are a little light on in defence and gone a little too big in the middle.. I suggest possibly downgrading 1 midpricer (gibbs,libba or crouch) in the middle for a rookie with greater scoring potential and add a little depth in the back half.
  Iv had lobbe in and out my side all pre-season but havnt heard good things out of port land so at the moment steering clear.. but from memory he never really has a good pre-season..
  Premos in forward line look great, still questioning dahlhaus but Jason would be able to give info there.. Sucking is a unique pick which could pay off.
  Your structure looks sound i would just focus on the defense a little
  Click to expand...
  
  Yeah, defence is really doing my head in again this year. Not sure who to pick.
  
  Ratmata, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #105
6. Ratmata
  
  walesy said: ↑
  
  Love the team!
  
  Love the triple rookie backline. Love the mid priced triple header in the mid line.
  
  It's like the perfect mix of my GnR team and Midpriced madness team, taking the best from both worlds.
  
  If those picks can step up, and your premiums fire, without a doubt, you'll be in with a crack!
  
  Only real question mark I'd raise is with Simpson- Though I think that's just me being ageist. His numbers are solid as ever.
  Click to expand...
  
  He's in purely because of the ps hype. We'll see how he fairs after a run in the NAB.
  
  Ratmata, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #106
7. walesy
  
  Bennell on talent alone is an easy selection- but he still hasn't rejoined the main group yet (gets back into it next week I believe) - which is a pretty big red flag.
  
  walesy, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #107
8. Grizzles
  
  walesy said: ↑
  
  Bennell on talent alone is an easy selection- but he still hasn't rejoined the main group yet (gets back into it next week I believe) - which is a pretty big red flag.
  Click to expand...
  
  Yeah I know see how he goes I guess. Heard on the radio the other day that he is hoping to play the last nab game. Has apparently put on 5kgs and has his best skin folds ever. Don't they all in the pre season?
  
  Grizzles, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #108
9. walesy
  
  Grizzles said: ↑
  
  Yeah I know see how he goes I guess. Heard on the radio the other day that he is hoping to play the last nab game. Has apparently put on 5kgs and has his best skin folds ever. Don't they all in the pre season?
  Click to expand...
  
  If he tears up the last Nab game, he'll come flying onto my radar I reckon.
  
  Definitely has the potential to be the F1, so long as he plays enough games!
  
  walesy, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #109
10. Jason
  
  Grizzles said: ↑
  
  Here is my current team!
  A lot to spend in the rucks but I think it should equate to at least a 50pt advantage over most teams. They both ruck solo for their respective teams and are both very durable.
  Parker under priced by a fair amount in my eyes due to his injuries and would love to squeeze Wines in for the same reason. Think bother will average 110+ this year.
  I like Bennel over Barlow for supercoach. Hopefully his calf is alright but I think that Lyon won't take any of his crap and hopefully he pushes his average north by another 5+.
  
  What do the great minds think?
  
  Click to expand...
  
  Bartel won't play 22 games, coach was quoted yesterday confirming as much. I generally don't like starting keepers who I know will miss some games, so I won't be choosing Bartel.
  
  Otherwise, nice structure. I like plenty of the selections because you a lot of the same names as my team!
  
  Jason, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #110
11. Penske file
  
  Jason like your backs and ruck, still need convincing on Wells, Mids a work in progress.I'm sure you have a forward thinking plan
  
  Penske file, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #111
12. Len
  
  Grizzles said: ↑
  
  Here is my current team!
  A lot to spend in the rucks but I think it should equate to at least a 50pt advantage over most teams. They both ruck solo for their respective teams and are both very durable.
  Parker under priced by a fair amount in my eyes due to his injuries and would love to squeeze Wines in for the same reason. Think bother will average 110+ this year.
  I like Bennel over Barlow for supercoach. Hopefully his calf is alright but I think that Lyon won't take any of his crap and hopefully he pushes his average north by another 5+.
  
  What do the great minds think?
  
  Click to expand...
  
  Strong squad, not totally sold on Bartel and Mal, and Bennell would be subject to fitness, but has a lot of the same feel as my current one.
  
  Len, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #112
13. Jason
  
  Penske file said: ↑
  
  Jason like your backs and ruck, still need convincing on Wells, Mids a work in progress.I'm sure you have a forward thinking plan
  Click to expand...
  
  But I don't have Wells in my team?
  
  Jason, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #113
14. tobes_123
  
  Grizzles said: ↑
  
  Here is my current team!
  A lot to spend in the rucks but I think it should equate to at least a 50pt advantage over most teams. They both ruck solo for their respective teams and are both very durable.
  Parker under priced by a fair amount in my eyes due to his injuries and would love to squeeze Wines in for the same reason. Think bother will average 110+ this year.
  I like Bennel over Barlow for supercoach. Hopefully his calf is alright but I think that Lyon won't take any of his crap and hopefully he pushes his average north by another 5+.
  
  What do the great minds think?
  
  Click to expand...
  
  Like a couple of the others im not convinced with bartel as he wont be playing 22 games, for 5k less birchall is a much better option I would think and he has been training with the midfield during the pre season.
  
  tobes_123, Feb 18, 2016
  
  #114
15. Penske file
  
  Whoops! Same comments at Grizzles. Sorry Jason.
  
  Penske file, Feb 19, 2016
  
  #115
16. Spirio43
  
  wonder if kerridge will be the 1st player in history to be in 100% of teams
  
  Spirio43, Feb 19, 2016
  
  #116
17. walesy
  
  Spirio43 said: ↑
  
  wonder if kerridge will be the 1st player in history to be in 100% of teams
  Click to expand...
  
  You'll certainly know what percentage of the comp has any clue, won't you.
  
  walesy, Feb 19, 2016
  
  #117
18. Spirio43
  
  walesy said: ↑
  
  You'll certainly know what percentage of the comp has any clue, won't you.
  Click to expand...
  
  very true
  
  After watching last nights game, interesting to see that there hasn't been much love to Gibson this year.. Smitch always get overlooked so thats no surprise.. In other news, Daisy keeps that sort of performance up and he will be on everyone's radar(and i for 1 hope that he stays off cause every time iv gone to watch he has looked good)
  
  Spirio43, Feb 19, 2016
  
  #118
19. Nick
  
  That KI Guy said: ↑
  
  Yeah I'm firming on Yeo now with Masten out and Sheed not 100%.
  Still like Simpson in there too though. Really want eski but think risk is too much if I take Libba and wells too.
  Click to expand...
  
  What are people's thoughts on Easton Wood as an alternative to Yeo or McMillan?
  
  Nick, Feb 19, 2016
  
  #119
20. walesy
  
  Spirio43 said: ↑
  
  very true
  
  After watching last nights game, interesting to see that there hasn't been much love to Gibson this year.. Smitch always get overlooked so thats no surprise.. In other news, Daisy keeps that sort of performance up and he will be on everyone's radar(and i for 1 hope that he stays off cause every time iv gone to watch he has looked good)
  Click to expand...
  
  Daisy's an interesting prospect, but you just look at the names that were off for the Blues last night (namely, Murphy and Gibbs) and wonder if that contributed to his scores.
  
  walesy, Feb 19, 2016
  
  #120
(You must log in or sign up to reply here.)

Show Ignored Content

Page 6 of 8
< Prev 1 ← 3 4 5 6 7 → 8 Next >

Share This Page

Search