2016 AFL Trade Week(s)

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, Oct 10, 2016.

By walesy on Oct 10, 2016 at 11:03 AM
  1. walesy

    walesy Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2015
    Messages:
    3,872
    Likes Received:
    2,565
    Boom. Trade week.

    I'll keep this post updated with the latest new that drops.

    10/10/2016

    Daniel Wells has nominated Collingwood as his new home under free agency #NABTradeRadio
    Vickery to the Hawks. Richmond get a 2nd rounder as Compo.

    11/10/2016

    The GIANTS have received pick 3 from @freodockers in exchange for Cameron McCarthy and picks 7, 33 & 71

    12/10/2016

    Chris Mayne to Collingwood as a UFA

    13/10/2016

    Freo send their Second (23) to Hawthorn for Brad Hill

    Brisbane get Picks 3 and 16 from GWS for Picks 2, 31, 51 and 60

    14/10/2016

    St Kilda recieve Jack Steele from the GWS for a future Round 2 selection

    WCE recieve Sam Mitchell, pick 54 and pick 72 from Hawthorn for Picks 52, 70 and 88

    Hawthorn recieve Tom Mitchell and pick 57 from Sydney for pick 14 and 52

    Hawthorn pick up pick 10 and 68 from St Kilda in exchange for 23, 36 and the Hawks 2017 first rounder

    17/10/2016

    Nathan Brown to St Kilda as a free Agent
    North receive Paul Ahern from GWS for pick 69

    18/10/2016

    3 Way
    GC: Hanley and pick 67 for Pick 22 and 30
    Port: Pick 19, 30 for 2017 1st rounder and pick 67
    Lions: Pick 22, Ports 2017 1st for Hanley and pick 19

    Melb receive Jordan Lewis, Pick 57 and 68 from Hawthorn for Pick 48 and 66

    Freo receive Joel Hamling and Pick 40, 63 from the Dogs for Pick 35, 43

    19/10/2016

    Melbourne receive Hibberd and Pick 59 from the Bombers for pick 29, 68

    Richmond receive Prestia and pick 24 from the Suns for Pick 6 and the Tigers 2017 2nd Rounder

    Richmond reveive Nankervis from Sydney for pick 46

    20/10/2016

    Suns get Witts from Collingwood for pick 44, 63

    Suns receive pick 35, 43 from Dogs for Picks 26 and 80

    North receive Hrovat, Dogs 2017 3rd and 4th Rounder from Dogs for North 2017 3rd and 4th rounder

    Freo pick up Kersten from Geelong for Pick 63

    Cats get Tuohy and Blues 2017 2nd Rounder for Smedts, Pick 63 and the Cats 2017 1st Rounder

    Richmond receive Caddy and pick 56 from the Cats for Pick 24 and 64

    Swans get Pick 31 from the Giants for Picks 39 and 52

    Suns receive Jarryd Lyons and Pick 71 from the Crows for Pick 43 and 67

    Melbourne get Pay McKenna and pick 51 from the Giants for Pick 57 and 59

    Eagles get Vardy from the Cats for pick 72

    Dogs get Cloke from Collingwood for Pick 76

    Essendon into James Stewart from the Giants for Pick 77

    Geelong get Aaron Black from North for pick 92

    Collingwood get Will Hoskin-Elliot from the Giants for the Pies 2017 2nd Rounder

    North pick up Marley Williams for a bag of chips (Pick 105)

    Collingwood pick up Lynden Dunn and Pick 51 from the Dees for Pick 47

    Suns pick up Pick 73 and Dockers 2017 2nd Rounder, Freo get Pick 35, 71 and the Suns 2017 4th Rounder

    Saints get Koby Stevens, Pick 61 and the Dogs 4th Rounder, the Dogs get Pick 50 and the Saints 2017 5th Rounder

    Carlton receive Rhys Palmer from the Giants for Pick 135

    Carlton receive Marchbank, Pickett and the Giants 2017 2nd Rounder, Giants get Pick 45, 58 and the Blues 2017 1st Rounder

    Giants get Deledio, Richmond pick up the Giants 2017 1st and 2017 3rd Rounders

    Carlton receive Pick 48, 66 and 70 from Hawthorn for the Blues 2017 2nd Rounder

    Hawks get Jom, Suns receive Pick 10 and the Blues 2017 2nd Rounder

    Port get Pick 14, 17 and 31, Swans pick up Pick 9, 19 and 49
     
    Last edited: Oct 20, 2016
    walesy, Oct 10, 2016
    #1

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, Oct 10, 2016.

  • Page 3 of 6
    1. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      I would be getting on the phone to Hawthorn right now if I was the others clubs. They are over a barrel trying to get JOM and looks like will do anything to get him.

      Losing Mitchell for spare change, ffs. As much as their trading is talked up I think it's a lot of hindsight bias (per the recent trades, Silk for Williams was awesome) because of the premierships. Eg McEvoy helped with the 3-peat but Saints walked away with theft in that trade deal. Like the T.Boyd deal. At least the Brad Hill deal was good (thanks arbitrary AFL FA compensation) though.
      port_leschenault, Oct 14, 2016
      #41
    2. Len
      Len
      Not quite a Duck if the other party was a staffer and not a team mate's missus?
      • Like Like x 1
      Len, Oct 14, 2016
      #42
    3. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      I agree that trade looks way overs just to get pick 10 to trade to the Suns for JOM.

      Surely if you want to overpay in a trade in that situation it is with the Suns and not a 3rd party ??
      TheTassieHawk, Oct 14, 2016
      #43
    4. graeme
      graeme
      The trading for picks by the Hawks is interesting. There are formulae that tell you what the trades are "worth" - a win to the Saints. Simple, except they remind me of the definition of an Accountant. One who know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

      If O'Meara were injury free at the start of next year and plays to potential what is he worth? Way more that pick 10 and the add ons. That is value. The cost ("overpaying for a trade pick") is irrelevant if that were to happen. I think there is a real chance that O'Meara, Titich and the remaining top line Hawks - along with some potentially excellent youngsters - will go deep next year. If injuries bite, maybe not even top 8. But a rejuvenated Hawks team could be deep in the mix for mine.

      The trade of Sam Mitch is fine in my book. You should have respect for a champion. But when he is ready, having seen another coaching approach, he will replace Clarkson. And I suggest be in a position to do much better than the one club guys like Buckley, Voss and Hird.
      • Like Like x 1
      graeme, Oct 14, 2016
      #44
    5. walesy
      walesy
      Yeah, not quite as juicy. Still, rating highly on the juic-o-scale however.
      • Like Like x 2
      walesy, Oct 14, 2016
      #45
    6. walesy
      walesy
      I agree.

      People complain mercilessly when that exact same formula is used by the academy teams to draft their academy players, claiming that the lower picks are worth too much.

      Suddenly a team "overpays" with the lower picks, and they've been barrelled. Can't have it both ways!!
      walesy, Oct 14, 2016
      #46
    7. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      I never mentioned any formulas. You can overpay in a trade and still have it work. See McEvoy, Tom Boyd et all.

      If JOM plays like his potential pre-injuries was indicating and helps extend the premiership window that will be a great pay off of Hawks. If he's a shadow of his former self or redoes an injury than losing several high picks for 2 drafts and at least one player will hurt them severely in the long term.

      It's a big call to make. Will define Wrighty's legacy imo.
      port_leschenault, Oct 15, 2016
      #47
    8. graeme
      graeme
      Agree with you completely port. I was suggesting the commentators / fans who say "two bags of x is equal to three bags of y" therefore the trade of picks is unbalanced, miss the bigger picture you so beautifully depicted.
      graeme, Oct 15, 2016
      #48
    9. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      Ah ok, I getcha now, graeme. Yeah, using the ranking points for draft picks that the AFL use to judge academy or f/s picks and applying it to trades is a bit disingenuous.
      port_leschenault, Oct 15, 2016
      #49
    10. walesy
      walesy
      Sounds like the Dees are making moves this period.

      Hibberd, Lewis, Rocky, Tippett. Dunno how they get it all done though!
      walesy, Oct 15, 2016
      #50
    11. port_leschenault
      port_leschenault
      The devil will be in the details.

      [​IMG]
      port_leschenault, Oct 16, 2016
      #51
    12. Len
      Len
      Jack Steele and Nathan Brown now Saints
      Ahern now a (one legged) Kangaroo
      Sam Mitchell an Eagle
      Tom Mitchell a Hawk
      Brad Hill an anchor
      Len, Oct 17, 2016
      #52
    13. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      yesterday was a yawn, hope there are some moves today and tomorrow rather than just the late flurry on Thursday prior to the deadline
      • Like Like x 1
      TheTassieHawk, Oct 18, 2016
      #53
    14. walesy
      walesy
      Ask and thee shall receive.

      GC - Hanley 67
      Bris - Ports Future 1st, Pick 22
      Port - Pick 19 30

      The hell are Port thinking? They gotta finish top 4 to come close to breaking even in that trade. Got a chance to turn a bad year into an absolute shocker with this one!
      • Like Like x 1
      • Dislike Dislike x 1
      walesy, Oct 18, 2016
      #54
    15. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      • Like Like x 1
      TheTassieHawk, Oct 18, 2016
      #55
    16. Len
      Len
      Jordan Lewis to Dees for free essentially, wow, salary cap pressure must be huge
      Len, Oct 18, 2016
      #56
    17. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      I suspect that is quite likely, although I hold out hope the Hawks are freeing up space for player/s at the end of 2017 and as remaining veterans retire.
      • Like Like x 1
      TheTassieHawk, Oct 18, 2016
      #57
    18. That KI Guy
      That KI Guy
      Although I have bias, I don't think this is a bad move from Port. Getting 2 second rounders in a deep pool and still retaining pick 9 this year, feels good. Re trading next years' 1st rounder, I'd think that making finals would be more than enough to break even here.
      That KI Guy, Oct 18, 2016
      #58
    19. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk, Oct 18, 2016
      #59
    20. Jason
      Jason
      [​IMG]
      Jason, Oct 18, 2016
      #60
    Page 3 of 6

Share This Page