2017 Round 3 Teams and Discussion

Discussion in 'Blog' started by TheTassieHawk, Apr 6, 2017.

By TheTassieHawk on Apr 6, 2017 at 11:49 PM
  1. TheTassieHawk

    TheTassieHawk SC fanatic Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    5,042
    Likes Received:
    3,657
    A fairly large set of fresh rookies are already named in the 18 or 22 for this weekend.

    J Dawson (123.9k FM, page 335 of the 2017 prospectus), Balic (123.9k FM, p134), Logue (180.3k D, p141), Berry (139.8k DM, p56), McLuggage (202.8k FM, p62), Durdin (123.9k F, p256), Parsons (117.3k F, p168), and T Smith (102.4k F, p248).

    With B Long (117.3k DF, p319), L Dawson (195.1k DF, p58), H McKay (123.9k F, p81), Williamson (117.3k D, p86) and J Stewart (169.8k F, p126) on the 7 man interchange there is potential for one or 2 of those to join them

    Jy Simpkin - edit and Ben Ainsworth - is out injured, while several rookies are also named on the 7 man bench including T Miles (F/M), Macreadie (D), Pickett (F/M), McGrath (D/M) and Barrett (M).

    Which means Preuss, Pickett, Eddy, Pickett, Bowes and Florent amongst others definitely have another run this weekend.

    Of the sub $200k rookies dropped after Round 1 Shoenmakers, Mountford and Hibberd failed to make the 25 for Round 3, while Foote returns for Sydney and Menzel is an emergency for the Crows.

    Hayward, N Newman, Burton, D Swallow and Broomhead are amongst the rookies who back up for their 2nd consecutive games.

    No D Cameron for the Swans (missing the 25) with Callum Sinclair picked to replace Tippett.

    I am not sure whether N Roo actually plays on Sunday, fingers crossed for those who held him.

    ----------------

    Sydney Swans v Collingwood
    Friday April 7 at the SCG (7.50pm)

    SWANS
    B: N.Smith, A.Aliir, N.Newman
    HB: C.Mills, H.Grundy, H.Marsh
    C: Z.Jones, J.Kennedy, J.Lloyd
    HF: O.Florent, L.Franklin, L.Parker
    F: G.Hewett, S.Reid, W.Hayward
    FOL: S.Naismith, D.Hannebery, K.Jack
    I/C: J.Dawson, J.Foote, R.Fox, C.Sinclair
    EMG: H.Cunningham, S.Edwards, J.Laidler

    IN: C.Sinclair, J.Foote, J.Dawson
    OUT: K.Tippett, J.Laidler, H.Cunningham

    MAGPIES
    B: J.Howe, H.Schade, J.Ramsay
    HB: J.Smith, B.Reid, B.Maynard
    C: S.Sidebottom, S.Pendlebury, J.Crisp
    HF: T.Varcoe, J.White, T.Broomhead
    F: A.Fasolo, D.Moore, C.Mayne
    FOL: B.Grundy, A.Treloar, T.Adams
    I/C: T.Goldsack, L.Greenwood, T.Phillips, W.Hoskin-Elliott
    EMG: J.Blair, J.Aish, L.Dunn

    IN: T.Varcoe, L.Greenwood
    OUT: J.Blair, J.Aish

    North Melbourne v GWS Giants
    Saturday April 8 at Blundstone Arena (1.45pm)

    KANGAROOS
    B: M.Williams, R.Tarrant, L.McDonald
    HB: J.Macmillan, L.Hansen, A.Mullett
    C: T.Garner, B.Cunnington, S.Atley
    HF: N.Hrovat, M.Daw, T.Dumont
    F: L.Thomas, B.Brown, K.Turner
    FOL: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, S.Higgins
    I/C: A.Swallow, S.Durdin, B.Preuss, S.Gibson
    EMG: R.Clarke, E.Vickers-Willis, C.Wagner

    IN: T.Goldstein, S.Durdin
    OUT: S.Thompson, J.Simpkin

    GIANTS
    B: Z.Williams, P.Davis, M.Buntine
    HB: J.Kelly, A.Tomlinson, A.Kennedy
    C: H.Shaw, C.Ward, T.Greene
    HF: D.Smith, R.Lobb, S.Johnson
    F: R.Griffen, J.Cameron, T.Scully
    FOL: S.Mumford, D.Shiel, J.Hopper
    I/C: S.Reid, T.Taranto, N.Haynes, N.Wilson
    EMG: J.Patton, A.Corr, H.Perryman

    No changes

    Richmond v West Coast Eagles
    Saturday April 8 at the MCG (2.10pm)

    TIGERS
    B: A.Rance, D.Astbury, D.Grimes
    HB: R.Conca, B.Houli, B.Ellis
    C: K.McIntosh, D.Prestia, S.Grigg
    HF: D.Rioli, T.Elton, D.Butler
    F: D.Martin, J.Riewoldt, J.Castagna
    FOL: T.Nankervis, T.Cotchin, J.Caddy
    I/C: N.Vlastuin, B.Lennon, J.Short, K.Lambert
    EMG: J.Townsend, A.Miles, C.Menadue

    IN: T.Elton, K.McIntosh
    OUT: S.Edwards, B.Griffiths

    EAGLES
    B: S.Hurn, T.Barrass, S.Wellingham
    HB: J.Nelson, J.McGovern, E.Yeo
    C: M.Hutchings, M.Priddis, A.Gaff
    HF: M.LeCras, J.Darling, J.Redden
    F: N.Vardy, J.Kennedy, J.Hill
    FOL: J.Giles, L.Shuey, S.Mitchell
    I/C: B.Sheppard, C.Masten, J.Cripps, L.Jetta
    EMG: L.Duggan, S.Butler, W.Schofield

    IN: L.Jetta
    OUT: D.Sheed

    Geelong Cats v Melbourne
    Saturday April 8 at Etihad Stadium (4.35pm)

    CATS
    B: Z.Tuohy, T.Lonergan, A.Mackie
    HB: T.Stewart, L.Henderson, J.Thurlow
    C: M.Blicavs, J.Selwood, S.Menegola
    HF: J.Parsons, H.Taylor, B.Parfitt
    F: S.Motlop, T.Hawkins, D.Menzel
    FOL: Z.Smith, P.Dangerfield, C.Guthrie
    I/C: M.Duncan, L.McCarthy, J.Murdoch, T.Ruggles
    EMG: J.Bews, D.Lang, R.Stanley

    IN: Z.Smith, C.Guthrie, S.Menegola, J.Parsons
    OUT: R.Stanley, J.Cowan, G.Horlin-Smith, D.Lang

    DEMONS
    B: C.Salem, T.McDonald, J.Hunt
    HB: N.Jetta, O.McDonald, N.Jones
    C: B.Vince, D.Tyson, J.Harmes
    HF: M.Hannan, S.Weideman, A.Neal-Bullen
    F: J.Garlett, C.Petracca, T.Smith
    FOL: M.Gawn, C.Oliver, J.Viney
    I/C: J.Watts, B.Stretch, D.Kent, J.Melksham
    EMG: C.Pedersen, T.Bugg, J.Spencer

    IN: B.Vince, D.Kent, T.Smith
    OUT: J.Lewis, J.Hogan, A.Brayshaw

    Port Adelaide v Adelaide Crows
    Saturday April 8 at the Adelaide Oval (7.40pm)

    POWER
    B: D.Byrne-Jones, T.Clurey, D.Houston
    HB: M.Broadbent, T.Jonas, H.Hartlett
    C: B.Ebert, O.Wines, J.Polec
    HF: S.Powell-Pepper, J.Westhoff, C.Wingard
    F: J.Trengove, C.Dixon, A.Young
    FOL: P.Ryder, T.Boak, R.Gray
    I/C: K.Amon, J.Impey, B.Edddy, S.Gray
    EMG: M.White, J.Atley, N.Krakouer

    IN: H.Hartlett
    OUT: J.Hombsch

    CROWS
    B: A.Otten, K.Hartigan, R.Laird
    HB: B.Smith, D.Talia, L.Brown
    C: R.Douglas, R.Atkins, R.Sloane
    HF: T.Lynch, M.McGovern, R.Knight
    F: C.Cameron, T.Walker, E.Betts
    FOL: S.Jacobs, C.Hampton, M.Crouch
    I/C: J.Lever, J.Kelly, D.Mackay, W.Milera
    EMG: M.Poholke, T.Menzel, R.O’Brien

    IN: J.Lever
    OUT: J.Jenkins

    Fremantle v Western Bulldogs
    Saturday April 8 at Subiaco (7.40pm)

    DOCKERS
    B: E.Hughes, J.Hamling, L.Spurr
    HB: G.Ibbotson, M.Johnson, T.Sheridan
    C: S.Hill, L.Neale, B.Hill
    HF: L.Weller, C.McCarthy, E.Langdon
    F: M.Walters, S.Kersten, B.Grey
    FOLL: A.Sandilands, N.Fyfe, D.Mundy
    I/C: C.Blakely, H.Balic, G.Logue, H.Crozier
    EMG: M.Taberner, D.Pearce, J.Griffin

    IN: T.Sheridan, H.Crozier, B.Grey, H.Balic, E.Hughes, G.Logue
    OUT: Z.Dawson, D.Pearce, J.Griffin, N.Suban,C.Sutcliffe, D.Tucker

    BULLDOGS
    B: M.Adams, F.Roberts, J.Johannisen
    HB: M.Suckling, E.Wood, R.Murphy
    C: L.Hunter, L.Dahlhaus, M.Boyd
    HF: J.Macrae, L.Jong, J.Stringer
    F: T.McLean, T.Cloke, L.Picken
    FOLL: T.Boyd, M.Bontempelli, T.Liberatore
    I/C: Z.Cordy, T.Campbell, S.Biggs, C.Daniel
    EMG: C.Smith, J.Dunkley, B.Williams

    IN: T.McLean
    OUT: S.Crameri

    St Kilda v Brisbane Lions
    Sunday April 9 at Etihad Stadium (1.10pm)

    SAINTS
    B: J.Geary, N.Brown, S.Gilbert
    HB: J.Newnes, J.Carlisle, D.Roberton
    C: S.Savage, J.Steele, L.Montagna
    HF: J.Lonie, N.Riewoldt, M.Weller
    F: J.Gresham, J.Bruce, T.Membrey
    FOL: T.Hickey, S.Ross, L.Dunstan
    I/C (from): B.Acres, J.Billings, B.Longer, B.Long, J.Webster, P.McCartin, J.Sinclair
    IN: N.Riewoldt , B.Longer , B.Long , J.Sinclair
    OUT: J.Steven

    LIONS
    B: N.Robertson, J.Frost, D.Gardiner
    HB: S.Mayes, H.Andrews, T.Cutler
    C: D.Zorko, J.Berry, H.McCluggage
    HF: L.Taylor, E.Hipwood, D.Rich
    F: M.Robinson, J.Schache, D.McStay
    FOL: S.Martin, D.Beams, T.Rockliff
    I/C (from): T.Bell, R.Bewick, C.Beams, L.Dawson, M.Close, R.Lester, J.Barrett

    IN: C.Beams, L.Dawson, J.Schache, J.Berry, H.McCluggage
    OUT: R.Bastinac, R.Harwood

    Carlton v Essendon
    Sunday April 9 at the MCG (3.20pm)

    BLUES
    B: S.Docherty, C.Marchbank, S.White
    HB: K.Simpson, S.Rowe, L.Plowman
    C: S.Kerridge, P.Cripps, E.Curnow
    HF: D.Thomas, J.Weitering, J.Silvagni
    F: M.Wright, L.Casboult, S.Petrevski-Seton
    FOL: M.Kreuzer, B.Gibbs, M.Murphy
    I/C (from): C.Curnow, B.Smedts, H.McKay, R.Palmer, H.Macreadie, J.Pickett, T.Williamson

    IN: R.Palmer, S.Kerridge, T.Williamson, H.McKay
    OUT: D.Armfield

    BOMBERS
    B: M.Baguley, M.Hurley, B.Stanton
    HB: B.Goddard, P.Ambrose, J.Kelly
    C: T.Colyer, D.Heppell, O.Fantasia
    HF: M.Brown, C.Hooker, D.Zaharakis
    F: Z.Merrett, J.Daniher, A.McDonald-Tipungwuti
    FOL: M.Leuenberger, J.Watson, H.Hocking
    I/C (from): A.McGrath, D.Parish, M.Gleeson, J.Stewart, K.Langford, S.McKernan, M.Dea

    IN: M.Leuenberger, H.Hocking, M.Brown, M.Dea, J.Stewart
    OUT: B.Howlett, M.Hartley

    Gold Coast Suns v Hawthorn
    Sunday April 9 at Metricon Stadium (4.40pm)

    SUNS
    B: J.Harbrow, S.May, J.Bowes
    HB: K.Kolodjashnij, R.Thompson, A.Saad
    C: D.Swallow, G.Ablett, M.Rosa
    HF: J.Lyons, T.Lynch, B.Matera
    F: T.Miller, P.Wright, J.Martin
    FOL: J.Witts, M.Barlow, A.Hall
    I/C (from): A.Sexton, J.Lonergan, B.Fiorini, J.Leslie, S.Lemmens, J Grant (replacing B.Ainsworth), J.Joyce

    IN: J.Harbrow, B.Matera, J.Lonergan, B.Fiorini
    OUT: C.Ah Chee

    HAWKS
    B: B.Stratton, J.Frawley, S.Burgoyne
    HB: L.Hodge, R.Burton, J.Gibson
    C: L.Shiels, J.O’Meara, I.Smith
    HF: L.Breust, J.Gunston, C.Rioli
    F: T.Vickery, J.Roughead, P.Puopolo
    FOL: B.McEvoy, W.Langford, T.Mitchell
    I/C (from): R.Henderson, K.Stewart, T.Miles, B.Whitecross, J.Sicily, B.Hartung, K.Brand

    IN: B.Whitecross, K.Brand, B.Hartung, J.Sicily
    OUT: G.Birchall
     
    • Like Like x 3

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by TheTassieHawk, Apr 6, 2017.

  • Tags:
    1. RPritch
      RPritch
      Could probably take any one of WHE, Oliver, Higgins or Marchbank. Depends which way you want to play it though
    2. RPritch
      RPritch
      I understand your concern. 2 games is a very small sample size to tell that WHE will kill it. You could play it however you want and I definitely don't know what the best option will be. One tip I can give, since you mentioned him, is that Berry should be a very good cash cow in the near future, kid's a jet.
    3. Daz
      Daz
      Hey all, have been disciplined and only used one trade so far... looking to now jump off joel smith - which of these three is more legit: mackie, spurr or salem? or should i bank some cash and go for mcgrath? please and thank you :)
    4. Grizzles
      Grizzles
      I had Higgins in my team until the last minute TTH and reckon he is the one to pick out of them! Also Pritch i'm personally waiting to see what Newman does tonight and will probably bring him in for Smith next week if that helps you with any of those decisions?
    5. traviso
      traviso
      Contemplating Sympkin to Houston? or am i trading into a guy thats going to disappear?
    6. Hazey1977
      Hazey1977
      I reckon Simpkin will be a slow, season long burner. They want to get games into him. Houston not a must with some other rookies now coming through.

      Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
      • Like Like x 1
    7. Hazey1977
      Hazey1977
      Hanners to be back with a vengeance tonight?

      Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
      • Like Like x 3
    8. tk
      tk
      Ok. Decision made! I'm going to pass on WHE. I figure I'd rather kick myself all season for not bringing him in, than choosing to not to start with him and bring him in after R2 to then curse him each week as he flops (at around double the price of a true rookie).

      So. That makes it M.Murphy & Houston in this week.

      And in the next couple of weeks, I'll bring in either Newman or Berry for Smith.

      Everything I've read about Berry is very positive. Could be a great get for $140K and DPP if lives up to expectations.

      Fingers crossed Houston can keep his position in the team.
      • Like Like x 1
    9. ELeviathan
      ELeviathan
      Thinking Josh Kennedy as VC tonight against the Pies. Thumbs please
    10. tk
      tk
      Unless you need someone on the park in your forward line, I'd hold off on that trade. Patience is your friend. It sounds like a possible waste of a trade unless you really have to do it for some reason. Houston's JS isn't rock solid.

      I'm only going with Houston because I have to bring in a rookie-priced forward this week - I need to offload McCarthy anyway, and I also am angling to get the cash to upgrade to Murphy in the mids.
    11. Hazey1977
      Hazey1977
      Him or Pendles

      Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
    12. traviso
      traviso
      thanks guys.
    13. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      cheers boss
    14. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      cheers mate, you are probably right but I cant bring myself to picking him this early
    15. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Have Marchbank, it looks like the other 3 are the concensus standouts
    16. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      Best Buys - 2017 Round 4
      Trade Newman In. That is All.
      • Like Like x 8
    17. RPritch
      RPritch
      I know his disposal efficiency was apparently just over 50%, but I can't believe Grundy (my vc) managed only 105 after having 23 disposals, 7 tackles and 43 hit outs (not sure how many of these were effective, but felt like a fair few were when I was watching)
    18. Penske file
      Penske file
      I think I'm at about to say goodbye to Smith and HELLO Newman, if he performs again next week. @ RPritch scoring is hard to fathom , eg Treloar and Grundy DE obviously has quite a bearing on their scoring.
    19. anthak
      anthak
      Hey mate, I reckon Salem is best bet out of them three. If Mackie stays fit he also looks good.
    20. anthak
      anthak
      So, should I double up Pendles' 125?
      Thumbs or comments please
      • Like Like x 1

Share This Page