2017 Teams and Round 9 discussion

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, May 18, 2017.

By walesy on May 18, 2017 at 10:38 PM
  1. walesy

    walesy Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2015
    Messages:
    3,070
    Likes Received:
    1,195
    Don't forget, there's no Suns or Power this week.

    Or Rocky or Boyd or Libba or Butler or any rookies to speak of! Rough times.

    Treloar and Beams are back though- woo!

    Geelong v Western Bulldogs

    Friday May 19 at Simonds Stadium (7.50pm)

    CATS



    B: T.Stewart, T.Lonergan, Z.Tuohy

    HB: J.Kolodjashnij, L.Henderson, A.Mackie

    C: M.Blicavs, J.Selwood, C.Guthrie

    HF: J.Parsons, H.Taylor, S.Motlop

    F: D.Menzel, T.Hawkins, N.Cockatoo

    FOL: Z.Smith, P.Dangerfield, S.Selwood

    I/C: J.Bews, M.Duncan, S.Menegola, M.O’Connor

    EMG: G.Horlin-Smith, J.Murdoch, T.Ruggles

    IN: L.Henderson, S.Selwood

    OUT: R.Stanley, G.Horlin-Smith

    DOGS

    B: D.Morris, M.Adams, J.Johannisen

    HB: R.Murphy, E.Wood, B.Williams

    C: L.Hunter, L.Dahlhaus, J.Macrae

    HF: C.Daniel, T.Cloke, C.Smith

    F: L.Jong, J.Redpath, L.Picken

    FOL: T.Boyd, M.Bontempelli, M.Wallis

    I/C: M.Suckling, L.Webb, T.Dickson, B.Dale

    EMG: T.McLean, F.Roberts, J.Roughead

    IN: R.Murphy, T.Cloke, D.Morris, M.Wallis, T.Dickson

    OUT: M.Boyd, T.Liberatore, F.Roberts, Z.Cordy, T.McLean

    St Kilda v Sydney Swans

    Saturday May 20 at Etihad Stadium (1.45pm)

    SAINTS



    B: J.Geary, N.Brown, D.McKenzie

    HB: J.Newnes, J.Carlisle, D.Roberton

    C: J.Billings, J.Steele, L.Montagna

    HF: J.Gresham, N.Riewoldt, M.Weller

    F: T.Membrey, P.McCartin, J.Sinclair

    FOL: B.Longer, S.Ross, J.Steven

    I/C: L.Dunstan, B.Acres, S.Gilbert, K.Stevens

    EMG: S.Savage, J.Bruce, D.Minchington

    IN: K.Stevens, D.McKenzie, P.McCartin

    OUT: J.Webster, J.Bruce, D.Minchington

    SWANS



    B: D.Rampe, H.Grundy, N.Smith

    HB: N.Newman, L.Melican, Z.Jones

    C: J.Lloyd, J.Kennedy, C.Mills

    HF: G.Hewett, L.Franklin, I.Heeney

    F: H.Cunningham, S.Reid, T.Papley

    FOL: C.Sinclair, L.Parker, D.Hannebery

    I/C: W.Hayward, G.Rohan, K.Tippett, D.Towers

    EMG: A.Aliir, J.Dawson, O.Florent

    IN: K.Tippett, D.Rampe, G.Rohan

    OUT: J.McVeigh, H.Marsh, S.Naismith

    GWS Giants v Richmond

    Saturday May 20 at Spotless Stadium (4.35pm)

    GIANTS



    B: N.Wilson, A.Tomlinson, A.Corr

    HB: H.Shaw, P.Davis, Z.Williams

    C: D.Smith, D.Shiel, T.Scully

    HF: R.Lobb, J.Patton, T.Greene

    F: S.Johnson, J.Cameron, S.Reid

    FOL: S.Mumford, J.Kelly, C.Ward

    I/C: D.Lloyd, H.Perryman, L.Whitfield, T.Taranto

    EMG: M.Kennedy, M.de Boer, H.Himmelberg

    IN: T.Greene, H.Perryman

    OUT: S.Coniglio, H.Himmelberg

    TIGERS



    B: A.Rance, D.Astbury, D.Grimes

    HB: J.Short, B.Houli, B.Ellis

    C: J.Castagna, J.Caddy, S.Grigg

    HF: D.Rioli, S.Lloyd, S.Edwards

    F: D.Martin, J.Riewoldt, K.McIntosh

    FOL: T.Nankervis, T.Cotchin, K.Lambert

    I/C: I.Soldo, D.Prestia, C.Menadue, S.Bolton

    EMG: J.Townsend, A.Miles, C.Ellis

    IN: S.Lloyd, D.Prestia, C.Menadue, S.Bolton, I.Soldo

    OUT: J.Batchelor, T.Elton, O.Markov, C.Ellis, D.Butler

    Brisbane Lions v Adelaide Crows

    Saturday May 20 at the Gabba (7.25pm)

    LIONS



    B: D.Gardiner, H.Andrews, D.Rich

    HB: S.Mayes, J.Walker, N.Robertson

    C: M.Paparone, D.Zorko, R.Lester

    HF: L.Taylor, M.Close, J.Barrett

    F: T.Bell, E.Hipwood, B.Keays

    FOL: S.Martin, J.Berry, D.Beams

    I/C: R.Harwood, H.McCluggage, C.Beams, M.Hammelmann

    EMG: R.Bewick, R.Mathieson, A.Smith

    IN: D.Beams, M.Hammelmann, H.McCluggage

    OUT: T.Rockliff, R.Bewick, J.Schache

    CROWS



    B: L.Brown, K.Hartigan, R.Laird

    HB: R.Sloane, D.Talia, J.Kelly

    C: R.Atkins, B.Crouch, B.Smith

    HF: C.Cameron, T.Lynch, E.Betts

    F: A.Otten, T.Walker, W.Milera

    FOL: S.Jacobs, M.Crouch, R.Douglas

    I/C: J.Lever, J.Gallucci, C.Hampton, H.Greenwood

    EMG: J.Beech, D.Mackay, R.O’Brien

    IN: H.Greenwood, J.Lever, J.Gallucci

    OUT: D.Mackay, T.Menzel, J.Jenkins

    Collingwood v Hawthorn

    Saturday May 20 at the MCG (7.25pm)

    MAGPIES



    B: J.Howe, H.Schade, T.Goldsack

    HB: J.Smith, L.Dunn, B.Maynard

    C: S.Sidebottom, S.Pendlebury, D.Wells

    HF: J.De Goey, A.Fasolo, W.Hoskin-Elliott

    F: J.Blair, D.Moore, J.Elliott

    FOL: B.Grundy, T.Adams, A.Treloar

    I/C: J.Aish, L.Greenwood, T.Phillips, J.Crisp

    EMG: M.Scharenberg, C.Brown, M.Cox

    IN: A.Treloar

    OUT: B.Reid

    HAWKS



    B: B.Hardwick, K.Brand, T.Duryea

    HB: R.Burton, J.Gibson, L.Hodge

    C: I.Smith, S.Burgoyne, R.Henderson

    HF: L.Breust, J.Gunston, B.Hartung

    F: T.Vickery, J.Roughead, P.Puopolo

    FOL: B.McEvoy, L.Shiels, T.Mitchell

    I/C: D.Howe, W.Langford, T.O’Brien, B.Whitecross

    EMG: K.Stewart, K.Heatherley, J.Sicily

    IN: B.Whitecross, T.Vickery, T.Duryea, K.Brand

    OUT: J.Frawley, C.Rioli, B.Stratton, J.Fitzpatrick

    Essendon v West Coast Eagles

    Sunday May 21 at Etihad Stadium (1.10pm)

    BOMBERS



    B: M.Dea, M.Hurley, M.Baguley

    HB: J.Kelly, M.Hartley, D.Zaharakis

    C: D.Parish, Z.Merrett, B.Goddard

    HF: J.Stewart, C.Hooker, T.Colyer

    F: A.McDonald-Tipungwuti, J.Daniher, C.McKenna

    FOL: M.Leuenberger, D.Heppell, O.Fantasia

    I/C (from): A.McGrath, T.Bellchambers, J.Watson, J.Green, J.Merrett, D.Myers, C.Bird

    IN: C.Bird, T.Bellchambers, J.Merrett

    OUT: nil

    EAGLES



    B: B.Sheppard, T.Barrass, S.Hurn

    HB: S.Butler, J.McGovern, E.Yeo

    C: A.Gaff, M.Priddis, C.Masten

    HF: D.Sheed, J.Darling, M.LeCras

    F: F.McInnes, J.Kennedy, L.Duggan

    FOL: N.Vardy, S.Mitchell, L.Shuey

    I/C (from): J.Redden, S.Wellingham, J.Cripps, D.Petrie, J.Nelson, J.Hill, K.Mutimer

    IN: D.Petrie, J.Cripps, J.Nelson

    OUT: nil

    Melbourne v North Melbourne

    Sunday May 21 at the MCG (3.20pm)

    DEMONS



    B: M.Hibberd, O.McDonald, N.Jetta

    HB: J.Hunt, S.Frost, B.Vince

    C: N.Jones, C.Oliver, T.Bugg

    HF: C.Petracca, J.Watts, M.Hannan

    F: J.Garlett, C.Pedersen, D.Tyson

    FOL: T.McDonald, J.Lewis, J.Viney

    I/C (from): C.Salem, D.Kent, J.Melksham, S.Weiderman, A.Neal-Bullen, J.Wagner, J.Harmes

    IN: J.Melksham, A.Neal-Bullen, J.Harmes

    OUT: nil

    KANGAROOS



    B: S.Durdin, R.Tarrant, E.Vickers-Willis

    HB: L.Hansen, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan

    C: S.Gibson, B.Cunnington, S.Atley

    HF: K.Turner, J.Waite, M.Williams

    F: N.Hrovat, B.Brown, S.Higgins

    FOL: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, J.Anderson

    I/C (from): A.Swallow, L.McDonald, R.Clarke, A.Mullett, T.Garner, M.Wood, D.Mountford

    IN: J.Waite, A.Swallow, A.Mullett, T.Garner, D.Mountford

    OUT: T.Dumont, J.Simpkin

    Fremantle v Carlton

    Sunday May 21 at Subiaco (4.40pm)

    DOCKERS



    B: G.Ibbotson, J.Hamling, L.Spurr

    HB: L.Weller, M.Johnson, C.Sutcliffe

    C: S.Hill, L.Neale, B.Hill

    HF: H.Crozier, C.Blakely, M.Walters

    F: M.Taberner, C.McCarthy, S.Kersten

    FOL: A.Sandilands, N.Fyfe, D.Mundy

    I/C (from): E.Hughes, D.Tucker, T.Sheriden, N.Suban, D.Pearce, B.Grey, E.Langdon

    IN: N.Suban, S.Hill, T.Sheridan

    OUT: nil

    BLUES



    B: L.Plowman, S.Rowe, C.Marchbank

    HB: K.Simpson, A.Silvagni, E.Curnow

    C: S/Docherty, P.Cripps, B.Gibbs

    HF: S.Petrevski-Seton, J.Weitering, M.Wright

    F: Z.Fisher, J.Silvagni, M.Kreuzer

    FOL: L.Casboult, C.Curnow, M.Murphy

    I/C (from): N.Graham, D.Thomas, T.Williamson, D.Armfield, L.Jones, B.Boekhorst, D.Cunningham

    IN: D.Armfield, L.Jones, B.Boekhorst, D.Cuningham

    OUT: S.White

    Byes: Gold Coast Suns, Port Adelaide
     

Comments

Discussion in 'Blog' started by walesy, May 18, 2017.

    1. TheTassieHawk
      TheTassieHawk
      I am looking at 23 players before trades and will be giving Parsons a run at F7 on Friday night.

      I am not sure who will be traded out as yet out of Otten, Butler, Balic, Florent and others.

      I will be bringing in Myers (If in the 22) and either a D4/F5/M6 which should give me 24 players.
      • Like Like x 2
    2. anthak
      anthak
      I have changed my trade plans so many times this week, first hoping Balic would play. After news came through of his indefinite absence, I finally worked out another trade plan which I was really happy with, but now Butler's injury means my only real option is to trade Butler and Houston in fwds to avoid donuts. because I also have Eddy and Strnadica (because Nank in ruck to cover Witts).
      I'm gonna bring in Heeney, I shouldve last week, but decided to upgrade my D to Heater instead. Heeney was in my starting team until his pre-season injury forced him out. Now finally gonna bring him in.

      Means I need a cheap FWD rookie who is playing this week. I cant afford James Stewart unfortunately.

      Anyone else have an idea which one i should go for? There are actually quite a lot named this week!
      I'm currently thinking Durdin, because at least he is on the bubble, and he has a good bye for me.


      Heeney will be my final upgrade in FWD line, so whoever it is I bring in will sit on the bench with Eddy from next week on (bar byes).
      • Like Like x 1
    3. Penske file
      Penske file
      I was also looking at a donut on the fwd line with the Nank/Witts cover ended with Strnadica there no Balic and the bane of my life Pickett. Traded Hampton to Burton to swap to backline after this week as a stepping stone trade up to Docherty after byes, also unloaded Balic to Myers, this leaves me with 20 trades. Thoughts??
    4. insider
      insider
      Galluci @anthak ?
      Between greenwood Bolton and galluci he's my pick. Always a risk with debutantes obviously tho.
      I would've got him in but managed to wrangle balic to Myers and otten to Michael Johnson. Backline 1 away from being finished for me - Adams shaw hibberd Johnson z jones and marchbank to be upgraded after byes
      • Like Like x 1
    5. IPOD
      IPOD
      Well having SPP and Ryder will test my depth really wanted to hold on to SPP till he maxes out but wanted to avoid a donut or playing Zac Fisher on field. Can trade SPP for maybe Myers and play him in place on Taranto who I have to move forward (via Balic into the mids) with Ryder having the bye.
      TU - down SPP to Myers
      TD - save the trade play Fisher
      • Like Like x 2
      • Dislike Dislike x 1
    6. anthak
      anthak
      What about Durdin though? Do you think Galuci is ahead of him?
    7. insider
      insider
      Probably the same job security. Galluci more of an unknown. Durdin still an apprentice so to speak and only comes in when Scott Thompson headbutts some prick
      • Like Like x 1
    8. The_Swert
      The_Swert
      Tough times. Several matured rookies ready to cull but nobody to replace them with.

      Only 1 trade this week, Butler to Heeney.

      Hoping for more rookies on the bubble next week - maybe J Stewart, McNiece, McGinnis or Lloyd.
      • Like Like x 1
    9. ELeviathan
      ELeviathan
      That Butler out certainly creates some problems, and if Myers doesn't get named the problem is compounded.

      Does anyone have any insight into the job security of McInnes at West Coast?
    10. Bucko
      Bucko
      I'm bringing in Hibberd and can't understand why I've heard no mention of him as a trade in target this week.
      DEF $423k , B/E 80, Avg 95 (113 last week).
      He's averaging 28 disposals over 4 games, only blemish was a 56 against the Hawks, but he still had 27 disposals in that game - just butchered a lot of them and gave away a few free kicks.

      Otten to Hibberd costs you $63k - Am I missing something ?
      • Like Like x 2
    11. ELeviathan
      ELeviathan
      Am also wondering what Soldo's inclusion will do to Nankervis's points generation...
    12. insider
      insider
      I got him in after 1 game. That was enough for me to take a gamble on a prior top 5 defender. He may hit the 'supplement suspension' wall like a lot of the bombers did/are, but im hoping that theyre more mentally drained from it being dubbed the Essendon Saga and he escaped that being at Melbourne.
      A lot of ifs and buts and gambles I know, but I certainly rate him highly if that's any comfort for you
      • Like Like x 1
    13. Bucko
      Bucko
      Also some interesting Otten stats:
      Avg with Jenkins in the side: 57.75
      Avg without Jenkins: 101.25

      Jenkins out this week, trade Otten at your Peril !
      • Like Like x 1
    14. anthak
      anthak
      Thats a good trade. Ive already got Hib
    15. Royboy Forever
      Royboy Forever
      Like Anthak I have been working on a number of different options this week. I need to trade Rocky as I can't be without him for 3 weeks. I had already setup up the Nank/Witts move but now I have no Balic or Butler and Black and Pickett are out of favour - I should have traded one of them last week when I had the chance. With only two trades available I will still have a forward donut. I have $200000 in the bank and I am thinking Rocky to Mitchell and Butler to Billings.
    16. Waldo666
      Waldo666
      Spoilt for choice this week with VC options so thought I'd see what the polls say.....would be using Fyfe most likely if VC fails

      :1: Danger
      :2: Bont
      :3: JPK
      :4: Pendles
      :5: Treloar
      • Option 2 Option 2 x 6
      • Option 1 Option 1 x 5
      • Option 3 Option 3 x 1
    17. Waldo666
      Waldo666
      Yep, was all set to trade him this week but am now having second thoughts
    18. insider
      insider
      Macrae as a leftfield choice?
    19. Waldo666
      Waldo666
      Not a bad shout at all due to his consistency but would probably want it on someone with a higher ceiling
      • Like Like x 1

Share This Page