2018 Round 13 Teams, Discussion and Review

Discussion in 'Blog' started by TheTassieHawk, Jun 14, 2018.

By TheTassieHawk on Jun 14, 2018 at 11:21 PM
  1. TheTassieHawk

    TheTassieHawk SC fanatic Staff Member

    Jan 3, 2016
    Likes Received:
    The byes part 2 - most of you are likely to still be in the foetal position after a particularly tough round 12 so hopefully this week is much kinder to all of us

    ROUND 13 TEAMS (All times AEST)

    Thursday June 14, 7:50pm at the Adelaide Oval

    B: Bonner, Hombsch, Houston
    HB: Byrne-Jones, Clurey, Pittard
    C: Motlop, Wines, Polec
    HF: Boak, Westhoff, Wingard
    F: S. Gray, Dixon, R. Gray
    FOLL: Ryder, Rockliff, Ebert
    I/C: Howard, Powell-Pepper, Marshall, Thomas
    EMG: Amon, Johnson, Trengove, Toumpas

    IN: Hombsch, Marshall, Thomas
    OUT: Jonas, Watts, Neade

    B: Williams, Trengove, Richards
    HB: Crozier, Cordy, Wood
    C: Johannisen, Hunter, Lipinski
    HF: Daniel, Schache, Wallis
    F: Dahlhaus, Bontempelli, Gowers
    FOLL: Boyd, McLean, Macrae
    I/C: Webb, Honeychurch, Biggs, Smith
    EMG: Young, Dunkley, Roughead, Jong

    IN: Cordy, Wallis, Webb, Biggs
    OUT: Suckling, Morris, Dickson, Roughead

    Friday June 15, 7:50pm at the SCG

    B: Lloyd, Grundy, Smith
    HB: Jones, Rampe, Marsh
    C: Cunningham, Kennedy, Florent
    HF: Hewett, Franklin, Hayward
    F: Ronke, Rohan, Parker
    FOLL: Sinclair, Heeney, Hannebery
    I/C: Allir, Jack, McCartin, Papley
    EMG: Cameron, O’Riordan, Robinson, Rose

    IN: Allir, Jack
    OUT: Robinson, McVeigh

    B: Hurt, McGovern, Cole
    HB: Jetta, Sheppard, Duggan
    C: Masten, Redden, Gaff
    HF: Rioli, Brander, Cripps
    F: LeCras, Kennedy, Waterman
    FOLL: Naitanui, Yeo, Shuey
    I/C: Ryan, Sheed, Lycett, Nelson
    EMG: Hutchings, Darling, Petruccelle, Ainsworth

    IN: Masten, Brander, Shuey, Ryan
    OUT: Ah Chee, Hutchings, Darling, Barrass

    Saturday June 16, 1:45pm at Etihad Stadium

    B: Rowe, Jones, Simpson
    HB: Thomas, Weitering, Plowman
    C: Lang, Cripps, Kerridge
    HF: O’Brien, Curnow, Dow
    F: Wright, Kerr, Fisher
    FOLL: Kreuzer, Silvagni, Petrevski-Seton
    I/C: Casboult, Graham, Curnow, Lamb
    EMG: Mullett, Polson, Phillips, O’Shea

    IN: Casboult, Graham
    OUT: Cunningham, O’Shea

    B: Nyhuis, Ryan, Sheridan
    HB: Hamling, Wilson, Hill
    C: Cerra, Neale, Langdon
    HF: Blakely, Cox, Tucker
    F: Ballantyne, Kersten, Banfield
    FOLL: Sandilands, Mundy, Fyfe
    I/C: Giro, Matera, Brayshaw, Apeness
    EMG: Hughes, McCarthy, Crowden, Jones

    IN: Hill, Sandilands, Fyfe
    OUT: Pearce, Walters, Jones

    Saturday June 16, 4:35pm at Metricon Stadium

    B: Harbrow, Thompson, Joyce
    HB: Ballard, Leslie, Weller
    C: Schoenfield, Miller, Bowes
    HF: Holman, Lynch, Sexton
    F: Ah Chee, Day, Martin
    FOLL: Witts, Ainsworth, Swallow
    I/C: Lyons, Young, Rischitelli, Lemmens
    EMG: Powell, Heron, Wright, Spencer

    IN: Schoenfield, Lyons, Lemmens
    OUT: Heron, Brodie, Scheer

    B: Webster, Brown, Savage
    HB: Clark, Carlisle, Rice
    C: Newnes, Steele, Armitage
    HF: Sinclair, McCartin, Battle
    F: Gresham, Membrey, Billings
    FOLL: Longer, Ross, Steven
    I/C: Dunstan, McKenzie, Austin, Weller
    EMG: White, Marshall, Paton

    IN: Billings, Carlisle, Armitage, Longer
    OUT: Lonie, Coffield, Phillips, Hickey

    Saturday June 16, 7:25pm at MCG

    B: Burton, Frawley, Stratton
    HB: Duryea, Sicily, Hardwick
    C: Gunston, Mitchell, Howe
    HF: Smith, Ceglar, O’Meara
    F: Burgoyne, Roughead, Impey
    FOLL: McEvoy, Shiels, Breust
    I/C: Morrison, Puopolo, Henderson, Langford
    EMG: O’Brien, Whitecross, Brand, Glass

    IN: Langford
    OUT: O’Brien

    B: Hartigan, Talia, Doedee
    HB: Mackay, Kelly, Seedsman
    C: Gibson, Douglas, Atkins
    HF: Milera, Walker, Poholke
    F: Gallucci, Jenkins, Betts
    FOLL: Jacobs, Crouch, Gibbs
    I/C: Greenwood, Otten, Cheney, Wilson
    EMG: Hampton, Ellis-Yolmen, Fogarty, Murphy

    IN: Gallucci, Otten, Cheney, Wilson
    OUT: Brown, Murphy, Fogarty, Ellis-Yolmen

    GEELONG CATS v RICHMOND (Squads of 26)
    Sunday June 17, 3:20pm at MCG

    B: Henry, Blicavs, Stewart
    HB: Tuohy, Kolodjashnij, Bews
    C: Duncan, Selwood, Murdoch
    HF: Kelly, Buzza, Fogarty
    F: Parfitt, Hawkins, Gregson
    FOLL: Stanley, Dangerfield, Ablett
    I/C: Cunico, Guthrie, Jones, McCarthy, Menegola, Parsons, Simpson, Thurlow

    IN: Gregson, Guthrie, McCarthy, Simpson, Thurlow
    OUT: Black

    B: Rance, Astbury, Grimes
    HB: Short, Vlastuin, Broad
    C: Grigg, Martin, Graham
    HF: Castagna, Edwards, Butler
    F: Riewoldt, Caddy, Moore
    FOLL: Nankervis, Cotchin, Lambert
    I/C: McIntosh, B. Ellis, Higgins, Conca, C. Ellis, Garthwaite, Soldo, Rioli

    IN: Martin, Rioli, C. Ellis, Graham, Garthwaite, Soldo
    OUT: Miles, Menadue


Discussion in 'Blog' started by TheTassieHawk, Jun 14, 2018.

    1. Penske file
      Penske file
      Fielded 18 - a few under performers some injuries and 3 rookies so pretty happy with 1885 lost 2 of my leagues, Dusty continues to be a concern but I will persevere. Congrats to some big scorers over 2000. Next week Grrrrrr.
      • Like Like x 2
    2. Owen
      Managed to spit out a 2047 for my first decent score in ages. Back inside the top 1000. 18 on the field this week, but some concerns over McLean and JJK
      • Like Like x 5
    3. TheTassieHawk
    4. Cpt Pugwash
      Cpt Pugwash
      Thoughts? (It’s a bit Far-Out!)

      Doedee > Ahern (via Sicily DPP)
      Martin > Kelly
      Witts > Grundy

      14 Trades (Rank 1151) - playing for Pts

      Martin back in next week via Holman.
      • Like Like x 3
    5. IPOD
      My thoughts were Macrae - Oliver, Brayshaw - Ahern and L.Murphy - McDonald. Leaves 7 trades and 145k. Thoughts
      • Like Like x 2
    6. The_Swert
      Currently plans are:
      Doedee > Simpson
      Austin > Hurley

      Then either (pls vote):
      1: L Murphy > Redman
      2: E Phillips > Ahern

      An extra playing rookie should help in case of selection shock.
      Last edited: Jun 19, 2018
      • Option 2 Option 2 x 3
    7. anthak
      Great trades mate! Should hold you in good stead.
      I’ve voted for Ahern, but it’s a coin toss. I think Ahern because of his DPP.

      Also will depend on AFL team selections. I’m anxious after what’s been dished up the last two weeks.
      • Like Like x 2
    8. ike2112
      Yeah I even made the decision to forego what may have been best overall, to ensure wins in a given week. I took a hit when Port and GC were on the bye, but have then gone 2 for 2 in all but one of my leagues through the byes, including scoring 1943 this week.

      However I do wish I'd brought in Ryan. I had it all planned out so this week it was Coffield to Mihocek
      Holman to Ahern
      Doedee to McDonald and having $266k in the bank to upgrade someone else next week...
      ....then Macrae got hurt. If I'd brought in Ryan last week he'd have been relatively cheap and give me a player on field.

      Do I now go Macrae to Danger or Oliver and wait for McDonald? McDonald is more likely to rise in value, but then will he stay that high? He can't keep scoring above 110 can he?
      • Like Like x 1
    9. Cpt Pugwash
      Cpt Pugwash

      Doedee > Ahern (via Sicily DPP)
      Martin (YES Martin) > Kelly
      Holman > McDonald

      Avg 254pts OUT
      Avg 294pts IN (with better upswing)
      Calc.Diff: 400+ Pts

      Rnd 14:
      20 on-field
      11 Trades remaining

      • Like Like x 2
    10. ike2112_01
      Ooft, big call. I had been going to drop Martin a few weeks ago, wish I'd just done it. But as I'd already gambled bringing in Zach Merrett and Tom Rockliff and neither worked out I feel I'm going to have to use trades for them already, trading out Martin (and perhaps presumably trading him back in a months time) is too much for me.

      Is everyone going in on McDonald? I feel like he can't keep this scoring up, he wasn't going to get that great a score until 2 marks and 2 goals when the result was already decided vs the Pies.
      • Like Like x 1
    11. Cpt Pugwash
      Cpt Pugwash
      I can’t wait each week for him to turn it around. Could come back in in a few weeks (doubtful). He’s now ranked around 20th for Mids. Something isn’t right there. I’m playing for rank not so much league. GWS are improving and Kelly is fit again. And McDonald is a must.
    12. ike2112_01
      Good points.
      I've got the Macrae issue to sort just now though, they're saying 4 weeks by the look of it, I can't carry him that long.

      12 trades and only $26k, I had wanted to get started with final upgrades:

      Laird / Hurley / Savage
      Lloyd / Doedee / Richards // Coffield / Keeffe

      Macrae / Fyfe / TMitchell / Martin
      Cripps / ZMerrett / Rocklifff / Brayshaw // Phillips / Holman / Higgins

      Gawn / NicNat // English

      Heeney / Gray / Westhoff
      Sicily / Boak / Fritsch // TSmith / Giles-Langdon

      Was planning
      Coffield to MIhocek
      Doedee to McDonald
      Holman to Ahern
      That would have given me I think $266k for another upgrade next week (had thought Brayshaw or Phillips to Oliver or Danger)

      But I might now need to ditch Higgins this week just to get me 18 on field, and then move Macrae out next week.
    13. The_Swert
      I respectfully disagree on both points.

      Martin's value has dropped so much that trading him now would cost ~$70k depending on who you choose, and Martin is just as likely to average over the rest of the season the same as Kelly/Neale/Treloar etc.

      And McDonald is the top priced fwd/def, you would be buying at peak price. He has no history of playing as a premium and his performance is skewed by one big game. If you have him, well done. But I don't think he's a must have, especially as only 9% of players have him. Plus key forwards are usually up-and-down. Reminds me of Jarrad Waite in early 2016.

      Last week I might've said Macrae was a must have, because his scoring was consistently above other options, he had a history of being a premium scorer and his ownership was fairly high. But not TMac.
      • Like Like x 2
    14. stowie
      JJK out for 1 to 3 weeks... my trading has been fantastic this year haha

      Last edited: Jun 20, 2018
    15. Cpt Pugwash
      Cpt Pugwash
      I take your point Swert, any advice or alternative suggestions?
    16. The_Swert
      Well I'm looking at Westhoff next week. Port have a good draw for the rest of the year.

      But yes, forwards are falling over this year. When is Toby Greene back?
    17. Cpt Pugwash
      Cpt Pugwash
      I already have Westhoff, Gray, McLean, Heeney, Smith, Lambert, Sicily and a couple others. Old Mac will be Def.

      Green would be a nice inclusion. I’m waiting for his return to Swing Sicily back and Green in.
    18. TheTassieHawk
    19. IPOD
    20. ike2112_01
      So I decided to do Oliver over Wines having been on the PA guy all week.....
      Then forgot to actually do it before lockout. So now I gotta decide if I do Kelly or just leave it for next week since I am going to win all my games easily (I'm fielding 19 and projecting at 1890ish, none of my opponents are breaking 1600).

Share This Page