2019 PSD Lucky Find

Discussion in 'ORFFU' started by HOLKY, Mar 26, 2019.

  1. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Here it is guys, the thread for the 2019 PSD Lucky Find which is looking more like the Rising Star but that is still not always the case. Last year we saw a clash of styles, the new recruit vs the returning veteran. This year, we have contenders in both categories. A notable contender is Anthony Miles looking to take another shot after almost winning in 2015.
    As for the new kids, it could be anyone. Sam Walsh has a lot of hype but with the exception of 2017, 1st picks haven't done well. (Mind you, that's an unfair assumption given Petracca and Hopper had injuries)
    First round to follow
     
    • Like Like x 2
  2. YAD69

    YAD69 Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,565
    Likes Received:
    810
    Picked up by HPD @Batfink at pick 44 Xavier Duursma (NAB Draft pick 18) scores 67 in round 1 is my nomination.
     
  3. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Still going through some bugs with my spreadsheet so if I've made an error here, just let me know:
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R1 Votes:
    A. Miles (KOR) 5
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 4
    J. Ridley (SER) 3
    J. Clark (CBC) 2
    S. Walsh (BLA) 1
    (Scott, Davis and Parker missed the votes)
    Total:
    A. Miles (KOR) 5
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 4
    J. Ridley (SER) 3
    J. Clark (CBC) 2
    S. Walsh (BLA) 1
    Miles getting out of the blocks well again and Kennedy already doing better than last time. A few players missing selection but that happens with untested talent.
     
    • Like Like x 3
  4. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R2 Votes:
    B. Mihochek (GRT) 5
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 4
    M. Parker (GIS) 3
    Z. Butters (PAK) 2
    C. Rozee (BBU) 1
    (Collins missed the votes)
    Total:
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 8
    A. Miles (KOR), B. Mihochek (GRT) 5
    J. Ridley (SER), M. Parker (GIS) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK) 2
    S. Walsh (BLA), C. Rozee (BBU) 1
    It's pretty much always close with regards to placings in this comp. In this case, 5 points between Kennedy's 90 for 4 votes and Rozee's 85 for 1.
     
    • Like Like x 7
  5. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R3 Votes:
    C. Rozee (BBU) 5
    S. Walsh (BBU) 4
    S. Mumford (SOU) 3
    B. Smith (SER) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT) 1
    (Collins and Davis missed the votes, they were tied too)
    Total:
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 8, C. Rozee (BBU) 6
    A. Miles (KOR), B. Mihochek (GRT), S. Walsh (BLA) 5
    J. Ridley (SER), M. Parker (GIS), S. Mumford (SOU) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), B. Smith (SER) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT) 1
    Close pack still, much more like 2017 than 18.
     
    • Like Like x 5
  6. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R4 Votes:
    S. Walsh (BBU) 5
    S. Mumford (SOU) 4
    S. Collins (ARA) 3
    B. Smith (SER) 2
    J. Ridley (SER) 1
    Ridley in W def Duursma in L
    (Hore and Davis missed the votes)
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 10, A. Kennedy (BAN) 8,
    S. Mumford (SOU) 7, C. Rozee (BBU) 6
    A. Miles (KOR), B. Mihochek (GRT) 5
    J. Ridley (SER), B. Smith (SER) 4
    M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT) 1
    A bit early to call but it looks like the main chase could be Walsh v Mumford. Will it be 3rd time lucky for the Sandgropers?
     
    • Like Like x 4
  7. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R5 Votes:
    B. Mihochek (GRT) 5
    S. Walsh (BBU) 4
    J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Thurlow (KIM) 2
    S. Mumford (SOU) 1
    (Hore and Kent missed the votes)
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 14, B. Mihochek (GRT) 10
    A. Kennedy (BAN), S. Mumford (SOU) 8,
    C. Rozee (BBU) 6, A. Miles (KOR) 5,
    J. Ridley (SER), B. Smith (SER) 4
    M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), J. Thurlow (KIM) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT) 1
    Sam Walsh averaging more in the first 5 rounds than Tim Kelly did last year. Mihochek close behind despite only polling in 2 games, history shows that each winner also polled in the most or equal most games but Mihochek could break the mold there.
     
    • Like Like x 3
  8. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R6 Votes:
    S. Mumford (SOU) 5
    C. Rozee (BBU) 4
    B. Smith (SER) 3
    M. Hore (GIS) 2
    X. Duursma (HPD) 1
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 14, S. Mumford (SOU) 13
    B. Mihochek (GRT), C. Rozee (BBU) 10
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 8, B. Smith (SER) 7
    A. Miles (KOR) 5, J. Ridley (SER), 4
    M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), J. Thurlow (KIM), M. Hore (GIS) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT), X. Duursma (HPD) 1
    Mummy and Rozee rejoin the chase making it 4 in the main pack.
     
    • Like Like x 3
  9. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    2019 PSD Lucky Find R7 Votes:
    T. Thomas (SER) 5
    S. Walsh (BLA) 4 (W in MID)
    S. Mumford (SOU) 3 (W in IC)
    M. Hore (GIS) 2
    B. Smith (SER) 1 (W in MID)
    A. Miles missed the votes (W in IC), Garner and Atkins missed the votes.
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 18, S. Mumford (SOU) 16
    B. Mihochek (GRT), C. Rozee (BBU) 10
    A. Kennedy (BAN), B. Smith (SER) 8
    A. Miles (KOR), T. Thomas (SER) 5,
    J. Ridley (SER), M. Hore (GIS) 4
    M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), J. Thurlow (KIM) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT), X. Duursma (HPD) 1
    2 draws in a round that had 3 points separating 2nd from missing the votes. W > L, F/D > R > M > IC then lowest av wins.
     
    • Like Like x 2
  10. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Round 8:
    J. Lienart (BLA) 5
    M. Hore (GIS) 4
    D. McStay (EDN) 3 (L in FWD)
    T. Thomas (SER) 2 (L in IC)
    B. Mihochek (GRT) 1
    Clark and Davis missed the votes.
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 18, S. Mumford (SOU) 16
    B. Mihochek (GRT) 11, C. Rozee (BLA) 10
    A. Kennedy (BAN), B. Smith (SER), M. Hore (GIS) 8
    T. Thomas (SER) 7, A. Miles (KOR), J. Lienart (BLA) 5, J. Ridley (SER) 4
    M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG), D. McStay (EDN) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), J. Thurlow (KIM) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT), X. Duursma (HPD) 1
    Is it BLA or BBU?
     
    • Like Like x 1
  11. JPK

    JPK Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    3,632
    Likes Received:
    1,792
    In TSL its "BBU"
    You've actually changed the abbreviations for a few teams - no big deal though.
     
  12. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Yeah, I just went with it. I changed to BBU halfway and I just realised then o_O
     
  13. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Round 9:
    C. Rozee (BLA) 5
    B. Smith (SER) 4 (L in MID)
    S. Mumford (SOU) 3 (L in IC)
    D. McStay (EDN) 2
    B. Mihochek (GRT) 1
    Fort missed the votes, but tbh who could predict he'd debut with 100+
    Total:
    S. Mumford (SOU) 19, S. Walsh (BLA) 18,
    C. Rozee (BLA) 15, B. Mihochek (GRT), B. Smith (SER) 12
    A. Kennedy (BAN), M. Hore (GIS) 8
    T. Thomas (SER) 7, A. Miles (KOR), J. Lienart (BLA), D. McStay (EDN) 5,
    J. Ridley (SER) 4, M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), J. Thurlow (KIM) 2
    B. Gowers (GRT), X. Duursma (HPD) 1
    98 gets 1 vote this time. Also, a first-round midfielder facing an old-guard ruck. I think we've done this before.
     
    • Like Like x 3
  14. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Round 10:
    M. Hore (GIS) 5
    X. Duursma (HPD) 4
    S. Walsh (BLA) 3
    B. Smith (SER) 2
    J. Lienart (BLA) 1
    Atkins, Miles, Clark and Kent missed the votes
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 21,
    S. Mumford (SOU) 19,
    C. Rozee (BLA) 15, B. Smith (SER) 14,
    M. Hore (GIS) 13, B. Mihochek (GRT) 12
    A. Kennedy (BAN) 8 T. Thomas (SER) 7, J. Lienart (BLA) 6
    A. Miles (KOR), D. McStay (EDN), X. Duursma (HPD) 5
    J. Ridley (SER) 4, M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), Z. Butters (PAK), J. Thurlow (KIM) 2, B. Gowers (GRT) 1
     
  15. HOLKY

    HOLKY Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    1,295
    Likes Received:
    623
    Round 11:
    Z. Butters (PAK) 5
    J. Lienart (BLA) 4
    X. Duursma (HPD) 3
    J. Waterman (CGD) 2
    C. Rozee (BLA) 1
    Davis and Guelfi missed the votes
    Total:
    S. Walsh (BLA) 21, S. Mumford (SOU) 19,
    C. Rozee (BLA) 16, B. Smith (SER) 14,
    M. Hore (GIS) 13, B. Mihochek (GRT) 12, J. Lienart (BLA) 10
    A. Kennedy (BAN), X. Duursma (HPD) 8 T. Thomas (SER), Z. Butters (PAK) 7
    A. Miles (KOR), D. McStay (EDN) 5 J. Ridley (SER) 4,
    M. Parker (GIS), S. Collins (ARA), J. Hately (STG) 3
    J. Clark (CBC), J. Thurlow (KIM), J. Waterman (CGD) 2, B. Gowers (GRT) 1
    Well, it was Port Adelaide round this week.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  16. JPK

    JPK Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2016
    Messages:
    3,632
    Likes Received:
    1,792
    Jake Waterman is blue and gold, through and through!!!! :D:D:D
     
    • Like Like x 2

Share This Page