awesome response!!! i never really thought about cyril rucking, but that adds to the dilema of who you would choose! i like the ideas of pav or goodesy, i wonder who would win out of a team of lethals v a team of goodes?
Phil Carman is the most versatile, fittest and under rated player I've seen. Forget how he finished up; in his prime he was the greatest dominator of a game. One Norwood game in particular he played centre and kicked eight, regularly getting hit outs and marking full back kick outs. He would destroy a Pav or a Goodes. Only G Ablett Snr had anywhere near his skills, but he would never have kept up with Fabulous fitness wise.
Matthew Richardson? Played back at times towards the end of his career and on the wing too. Great forward, consistency would be a problem but if you had 22 Richo's playing his best footy than you'd have a great side I think.