This is absolute carnage between Mt Beauty and Darraweit - 4 players have gone down injured and been vested with a grand total of less than 60 points between them. Goddard, Nic Nat, Leuenberger and Menzel have all been hurt.
Foul Bay v Nunawading Foul Bay Def: Shaw (110), Bartel (129), Jaensch (109), Johnson (109) Mid: Liberatore (82), Selwood (126), Stokes (124), Kelly (107) Ruck: Mumford (0) Fwd: Roughead (99), Adams (127), Dangerfield (87), Pavlich (125) I/C: Vince (55), Spencer (88) TOTAL: 1477 Nunawading: Def: Broadbent (111), Haynes (86), Simpson (128), Geary (61) Mid: Kennedy (121), O'Meara (105), Stanton (114), Thomas (60) Ruck: Hampson (69) Fwd: Varcoe (74), Jones (93), Lisle (78), Dawes (68) I/C: Cross (101), Myers (0) TOTAL: 1269 Votes: 5 - Bartel (FBC) 4 - SImpson (NUN) 3 - Adams (FBC) 2 - Selwood (FBC) 1 - Pavlich (FBC) Match Report: Despite the final scoreline, the Chooks definitely had their work cut out for them in this one, needing a big second half performance to put the Nuffers away. Losing the Les W Medal leading Shane Mumford with no replacement left a massive, sausage eating whole in the side and some scratchy early performances from Vince, Liberatore and Spencer coupled with some fine games from Simpson, Broadbent and Liam Jones had left Foul Bay in a world of early pain. Saturday night saw the Geelong engine room of Selwood, Bartel, Stokes and Kelly rescuing the side like they have done so many times getting the game back on level terms heading into Sunday. Importantly, Patch Adams kept pace with the imposing JPK and then unluckily the Nuffers lost David Myers to illness. That seemed to buoy the evergreen Matthew Pavlich, the ever reliable Michael Johnson and the increasingly impressive pick 53 of the MSD Matthew Jaensch and the rest was history. Happy to get away with the win. Some interesting selection dilemmas looming at Foul Bay for next week.
[span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;]Wagga Wagga vs Larrikin Lagoon [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;]Match result: Wagga Wagga ([span style='color: #ff0000;]1212[span style='background-color: #ff0000;]) def Larrikin Lagoon ([span style='color: #ff0000;]962) [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;][span style='font-size: 16px;]Wagga Wagga [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] Def: Reilly (62), Dunn (68), R.Murphy (90), S.D.Thompson ([span style='color: #ff0000;]132) (O'Shea) Mid: Watson ([span style='color: #ff0000;]102), Bastinac (77), D.Swallow ([span style='color: #ff0000;]107), Prestia (70) (Sheppard) Ruc: Cox (77) Fwd: Schulz ([span style='color: #ff0000;]120), Franklin (29), Mayes (92), L.Thomas (24) (Impey) Int: Jenkins ([span style='color: #ff0000;]122), Kerridge (40) (Lycett) [span style='font-size: 16px;] [span style='font-size: 16px;]TOTAL: 1212 [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;]Lefties [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] Def - Baguley ([span style='color: #ff0000;]101), Golby (49), Duryea (51), Langford (70) (R Thompson) [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] Mid - Priddis (67), S Selwood (78), Cunnington ([span style='color: #ff0000;]126), Lewis (77) (Suban) Ruc - Currie (0 - DNP) Fwd - Hale (56), Daniher (71), P.Cripps OOP (74/2 = 37), Rohan (15) (Schofield OOP) I/C - Mzungu (59), Conca ([span style='color: #ff0000;]105) (Robertson) TOTAL: 962 The Wombats came out on top in an all-round scrappy game of football. The Lefties were extremely unlucky with Currie being a late out, Rohan getting the sub vest and a number of players under-performing. The Wombats had another inconsistent week, with Lindsay Thomas now almost certain to be dropped. Franklin showed us we're in for a roller-coaster ride. Les.W Votes: 5. Scott.D.Thompson (Wagga Wagga) 4. Ben Cunnington (Larrikin Lagoon) 3. Josh Jenkins (Wagga Wagga) 2. Jay Schulz (Wagga Wagga) 1. David Swallow (Wagga Wagga)
Nice work Chief. With Mummy gone I thought the Nuffers might sneak under the radar to cause a headline topping upset. The depth of your side is remarkable and when someone has a down day others eagerly step up to go large. I reckon you could get an 1800+ score one day when the boys all sing from the same hymn book.
Birdsville D: Enright (88), Houli (115), Laird (46), L McDonald (80) M: Ebert (129), Murphy (72), Treloar (105), Wells (107) R: Clarke (92) F: Cloke (33), Howlett (80), Jetta (54), White(119) IC: Moloney (85), Rischitelli (67) TOTAL - 1272 Gariwerd D: Pittard (80), Tuohy (28), BSmith (125), Guthrie (126) M: Cooney (73), KStevens (67), Polec (98), Cunningham (46) R: Nicholson (0) F: Gray (111), De Boer (105), Casboult (88), Evans (10) I: Wallis (61), MCrouch (80) TOTAL - 1100 Les W. Votes 5. Brad Ebert (Birdsville) 4. Cam Guthrie (Gariwerd) 3. Brodie Smith (Gariwerd) 2. Jesse White (Birdsville) 1. Bachar Houli (Birdsville)
JC wrote: Birdsville D: Enright (88), Houli (115), Laird (46), L McDonald (80) M: Ebert (129), Murphy (72), Treloar (105), Wells (107) R: Clarke (92) F: Cloke (33), Howlett (80), Jetta (54), White(119) IC: Moloney (85), Rischitelli (67) TOTAL - 1272 Gariwerd D: Pittard (80), Tuohy (28), BSmith (125), Guthrie (126) M: Cooney (73), KStevens (67), Polec (98), Cunningham (46) R: Nicholson (0) F: Gray (111), De Boer (105), Casboult (88), Evans (10) I: Wallis (61), MCrouch (80) TOTAL - 1100 Les W. Votes 5. Brad Ebert (Birdsville) 4. Cam Guthrie (Gariwerd) 3. Brodie Smith (Gariwerd) 2. Jesse White (Birdsville) 1. Bachar Houli (Birdsville) Thanks for the update JC Good game. We both had a similar amount of high performers, but I had 3 players score less than your lowest, Cloke.
Lenny120 wrote: [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;]Wagga Wagga vs Larrikin Lagoon [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;]Match result: Wagga Wagga ([span style='color: #ff0000;]1212[span style='background-color: #ff0000;]) def Larrikin Lagoon ([span style='color: #ff0000;]962) [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;][span style='font-size: 16px;]Wagga Wagga [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] Def: Reilly (62), Dunn (68), R.Murphy (90), S.D.Thompson ([span style='color: #ff0000;]132) (O'Shea) Mid: Watson ([span style='color: #ff0000;]102), Bastinac (77), D.Swallow ([span style='color: #ff0000;]107), Prestia (70) (Sheppard) Ruc: Cox (77) Fwd: Schulz ([span style='color: #ff0000;]120), Franklin (29), Mayes (92), L.Thomas (24) (Impey) Int: Jenkins ([span style='color: #ff0000;]122), Kerridge (40) (Lycett) [span style='font-size: 16px;] [span style='font-size: 16px;]TOTAL: 1212 [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 16px;]Lefties [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] Def - Baguley ([span style='color: #ff0000;]101), Golby (49), Duryea (51), Langford (70) (R Thompson) [span style='font-family: Arial; font-size: 13px;] Mid - Priddis (67), S Selwood (78), Cunnington ([span style='color: #ff0000;]126), Lewis (77) (Suban) Ruc - Currie (0 - DNP) Fwd - Hale (56), Daniher (71), P.Cripps OOP (74/2 = 37), Rohan (15) (Schofield OOP) I/C - Mzungu (59), Conca ([span style='color: #ff0000;]105) (Robertson) TOTAL: 962 The Wombats came out on top in an all-round scrappy game of football. The Lefties were extremely unlucky with Currie being a late out, Rohan getting the sub vest and a number of players under-performing. The Wombats had another inconsistent week, with Lindsay Thomas now almost certain to be dropped. Franklin showed us we're in for a roller-coaster ride. Les.W Votes: 5. Scott.D.Thompson (Wagga Wagga) 4. Ben Cunnington (Larrikin Lagoon) 3. Josh Jenkins (Wagga Wagga) 2. Jay Schulz (Wagga Wagga) 1. David Swallow (Wagga Wagga) Thanks Lenny, Yeah carnage felt by many this wk, no hope for my mid with the WCE massacre. Out of the mire, 'twas good to see Cripps, Robbo and Schoey gets some game time. Ironic that the Franklin freeze was at the expense of the Thompson ton. Will be plenty of coaches replaying that tape.
anthak wrote: JC wrote: Birdsville D: Enright (88), Houli (115), Laird (46), L McDonald (80) M: Ebert (129), Murphy (72), Treloar (105), Wells (107) R: Clarke (92) F: Cloke (33), Howlett (80), Jetta (54), White(119) IC: Moloney (85), Rischitelli (67) TOTAL - 1272 Gariwerd D: Pittard (80), Tuohy (28), BSmith (125), Guthrie (126) M: Cooney (73), KStevens (67), Polec (98), Cunningham (46) R: Nicholson (0) F: Gray (111), De Boer (105), Casboult (88), Evans (10) I: Wallis (61), MCrouch (80) TOTAL - 1100 Les W. Votes 5. Brad Ebert (Birdsville) 4. Cam Guthrie (Gariwerd) 3. Brodie Smith (Gariwerd) 2. Jesse White (Birdsville) 1. Bachar Houli (Birdsville) Thanks for the update JC Good game. We both had a similar amount of high performers, but I had 3 players score less than your lowest, Cloke. No worries Ant. The zero in the ruck and then Evans OOP plus the green vest really killed your chances. If I have enough forwards available next week, big Trav Cloke and his season avg of 41 will be off to spend some time in the two's.
Lilacs V Cradle Mountain Lilacs - 1,148 DEF - Adcock 87, Carlisle 59, Grimes 96, Hunt 100 MID - Swan 116, Duncan 101, Rosa DNP, Simpkin 38 (EMG - Lucas 60) FWD - Caddy 38, Edwards 81, Ballantyne 85, Chapman DNP (EMG - Winderlich 40) RUC - Pyke 70 I/C - Thompson 121, Langdon 56 Cradle Mountain - 1,270 DEF - Vlastuin 77, Spurr 60, Gwilt 69, Fletcher DNP (EMG - N Smith 82) MID - Pendlebury 129, Johnson 150, Redden 94, Heppell 133 FWD - Zorko 82, Hurley 66, Kennedy-Harris 49, Grigg 26(OOP) RUC - West 86 I/C - Zaharakis 71, Shiels 96 Cradle Mountain 1,270 Def Lilacs 1,148 Les W. Votes 1 - Johnson 150 (CM) 2 - Heppell 133 (CM) 3 - Pendlebury 129 (CM) 4 - Thompson 121 (LL) 5 - Swan 116 (LL)
ts leagues has me losing to TiB by 3 points !!!! David Mundy getting injured and subbed off was the difference, but you had a 0 on bench so very well done to get the W! Good encounter TiB!
Misfits taken to the slaughter house by the Cows, 793 to 1257. NDS 134 - WI S Jacobs 118 - WI M Wright 118 - WI J McVeigh 110 - WI C Hampton 109 - MBM
May need to double check these scores - I added these in a rush and may have missed something given all the injuries that occurred. Darraweit 1156 D: Walker 74, Frawley 131, Gibson 106, McKenzie 87 M: Goddard 11, Armitage 84, Tyson 50, Coniglio 78 R: Nic Nat 27 F: Westhoff 123, Harvey 57, Vickery 25, Hunter 65 I/C: Cornes 125, Hill 113 Mt Beauty 1084 D: Newman 77, Grimes 37, Kade K 64, Bugg 71 M: Boyd 153, Cotchin 65, Sidebottom 109, Hartlett 74 R: Leuenberger 0 F: Rioli 77, Nick Riewoldt 119, D Martin 94, T Menzel 13 I/C: Ellis 54, Viney 77 Darraweit 1156 d Mt Beauty1084 A forgettable match, with injuries and poor form pretty much across the board. Four players subbed out to injury, as well as a variety of spud-like efforts from the highly credentialed. Darraweit's backline - not for the first time in the past 12 months - was the difference in the win. One feels though that this match - and the injuries - could have ramifications in the weeks ahead. Les W: 5 - Boyd (MBU) 4 - Frawley (?!) (DGD) 3 - Cornes (DGD) 2 - Westhoff (DGD) 1 - N Riewoldt (MBU) Just as a query - If a situation happens where a gent like Leuenberger gets injured and records a 0 score, yet the team has an emergency, the 0 stands, doesn't it? Mt Beauty didn't have an emergency for Berger so in this case unfortunately he joins the parade of poor performances ... but I seem to remeber SC changed its rules after a debacle where a player took the field, was injured, recorded a 0 yet everyone got their emergency's score. What's our rule on this?
Fitzy wrote: ts leagues has me losing to TiB by 3 points !!!! David Mundy getting injured and subbed off was the difference, but you had a 0 on bench so very well done to get the W! Good encounter TiB! Whitsundays 1235 - 1232 Venus Bay Les W votes. 5. T.Boak (WSW) 4. D.Beams (VBV) 3. R.Sloane (WSW) 2. O.Wines (WSW) 1, S.Higgins (VBV)
Results ex tsleagues.. <table width='222' border='0' cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0] <col width='64' style='width: 48pt;[/img] <col width='64' style='width: 48pt;[/img] <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt; width: 48pt;]Home <td class='xl22' style='width: 35pt;] <td class='xl22' style='width: 48pt;]Away <td class='xl22' style='width: 35pt;] <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]PPP <td class='xl22]1,094 <td class='xl22]COP <td class='xl22]1,256 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]DGD <td class='xl22]1,156 <td class='xl22]MBU <td class='xl22]1,084 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]NWN <td class='xl22]1,268 <td class='xl22]FBC <td class='xl22]1,477 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]WWW <td class='xl22]1,212 <td class='xl22]LLL <td class='xl22] 962 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]LBL <td class='xl22]1,134 <td class='xl22]CMD <td class='xl22]1,270 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]BIB <td class='xl22]1,272 <td class='xl22]GWC <td class='xl22]1,100 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]GGH <td class='xl22] 967 <td class='xl22]IKC <td class='xl22]1,382 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]VBV <td class='xl22]1,232 <td class='xl22]WSW <td class='xl22]1,235 <tr height='17' style='height: 12.75pt;] <td style='height: 12.75pt;]MBM <td class='xl22] 793 <td class='xl22]WKI <td class='xl22]1,257
Thanks Len - have the matchday stats from tsLeagues so probably don't need the score list from here on in (thanks for posting that over the past 3-4 rounds though). I'll get onto the review today.
Done and dusted - http://tooserious.net/Home/tabid/90/Post/6934/The-Winners-ORFFA-Round-4-Review Enjoy everyone!
Fitzy wrote: ts leagues has me losing to TiB by 3 points !!!! David Mundy getting injured and subbed off was the difference, but you had a 0 on bench so very well done to get the W! Good encounter TiB! Close one Fitzy, but I probably needed it more than you did at this stage of the season. Enjoyable game - lots of tension.