What happened with Pearcedales team entry last week? Was it going to be entered? Or are we going with the ladder as is? Tipping Yad would be shattered. Makes a massive difference if Pearcedale beat Ararat last week. I was thinking I would choose Ararat if they are in the finals. Pakenham v Ararat first final or if things change Pakenham v Coolgardie. Some info needed commish thanks
The Lucky Find PSD is also affected as Ben McGlynn would have won had Pearcedale fielded a team... I think we're going with the current setup though but we'll have to wait for Tomster's ruling to be sure.
ddsaints wrote: Very pleased to have taken out the minor premiership, A lot of luck along the way has helpedwith some timely scores from the lesser lightsin some gamesto help get the job done. Losing Ablett has hurt my chances for the flag, but with a little more luck who knows......At least I can hang my hat on something, minor premier isa good thinga successful year without a doubt. Having first pick in finals is very important, no doubt ill make the wrong choice and be straight out. Thinking either Coolgardie or Ararat first final. Ill fill you guys in tonight. When is the cutoff for finals matchups? before teams are announced or after? Im thinking before teams are announced Im still working off of percentages
It's getting very late in the week to be changing things regarding Pearcedale's team last week. I think something has to be decided tonight or it stays as is. Also concerned that it's a big call to ride on 1 person's decision. Should it be put to a vote? And if so, should the vote maybe be just the people who aren't effected? ie. the bottom 7 teams. Of course the worry is at this late stage, we wouldn't get enough people voting. Just putting it out there as an idea.
Great thoughts Tylo, agree with everything you have written. A vote would be the best but a little hard like you said. Its a hard one for all involved I'm easy either way
I don't think it's a big call at all. All season regardless of rules any team not posted got the last posted team and that's been the applied rule from the Commish so why is TTT's team being the exception in round 20??? By TTT's own admission he was fielding a team it just didn't save, therefore a team should be recorded as being played be it last posted team or the one he intended to post, which would most probably have been 95% as his last posted team anyway. I hadn't posted anything before regarding this issue as I thought in the Commish post regarding the missing teams that the last posted team would be entered if he didn't get any replies on the site (responding to dd re: blowflys). The only and correct call is a team must be entered for TTT round 20, simple, end of story.
Tomster wrote: Unentered teams will be reverted to last weeks team entry. Discussion pending re. rules on this subject Quick timeline of upcoming events (happy for anyone to add anything) Thursday - Finals Week 1 Fixture finalised Friday - Finals Week 1 Begins Monday - Finals Week 2 opens Wednesday - End of season POOYA Awards Voting opens Thursday - Finals Week 2 fixture finalised Friday - Week 2 Finals begins Monday - Grand Final week begins Wednesday - POOYA End of Season Award Voting closes Friday - 1st ORFFU Grand Final Commences Monday - Mad Monday With that in mind..... Pearcedales RD 19 team would score the following in RD20 DEF: Shaw 126 Gibson 51 Smith 78 Kolod 90 MID: Mundy 119 Ray 75 Bennell 99 Conca 0 Thomas 123 RUC: Lobbe 100 FWD: McGlyn 134 Parker 120 Howe 110 Smith 115 I/C: Caddy 50 Lycett 98 Total 1488........giving Pearcedale a win over Ararat 1488 to 1093........as a point of interest the same team in RD 19 scored 1367. Sort it out from there you blokes. I'm off to cry in me beer, and ponder the meaning of life.....
choppers wrote: Tomster wrote: Unentered teams will be reverted to last weeks team entry. Discussion pending re. rules on this subject Quick timeline of upcoming events (happy for anyone to add anything) Thursday - Finals Week 1 Fixture finalised Friday - Finals Week 1 Begins Monday - Finals Week 2 opens Wednesday - End of season POOYA Awards Voting opens Thursday - Finals Week 2 fixture finalised Friday - Week 2 Finals begins Monday - Grand Final week begins Wednesday - POOYA End of Season Award Voting closes Friday - 1st ORFFU Grand Final Commences Monday - Mad Monday With that in mind..... Pearcedales RD 19 team would score the following in RD20 DEF: Shaw 126 Gibson 51 Smith 78 Kolod 90 MID: Mundy 119 Ray 75 Bennell 99 Conca 0 Thomas 123 RUC: Lobbe 100 FWD: McGlyn 134 Parker 120 Howe 110 Smith 115 I/C: Caddy 50 Lycett 98 Total 1488........giving Pearcedale a win over Ararat 1488 to 1093........as a point of interest the same team in RD 19 scored 1367. Sort it out from there you blokes. I'm off to cry in me beer, and ponder the meaning of life..... What! Mad Monday's after the GF! I'll call what happened this Monday training then...
Fwiw I had the same team not saved issue 2 weeks ago during the split round where my changes didn't save. Only noticed after the Fri night game so re entered as per my posted team
I don't really care but I'm pretty sure not every team that missed team entry during the year was re entered after the round had finished, we had a few donuts from teams. It doesn't bother me either way really. It's a shame it's turned out like this. Could be a lot easier
ddsaints wrote: I don't really care but I'm pretty sure not every team that missed team entry during the year was re entered after the round had finished, we had a few donuts from teams. It doesn't bother me either way really. It's a shame it's turned out like this. Could be a lot easier +1. The ladder won't be changing, too hard to do at this stage. Either way, I'm tipping both teams would have been knocked out first round. Good luck to all those playing this weekend
The Cuda's also take exception that we'd be bundled out in the first round of the finals as well especially with last weeks score of 1,368, 3 game average of 1,316 & a 5 game average of 1,289.
7hs til 'lockout' tick tick tick The commish has made the call, which is what he is elected to do and full marks for making a call which we should abide by! However given the precedent set throughout the year (teams is submitted based on last round) I agree Cuda that you have been hard done by. I think I have been hypnotized by my twitter feed 'precendent' and all the AFL / ASADA / EFC legal speak this week. Good luck to those playing finals this week it looks like my bulls may be going back to the dance with Goondiwindi again with some key inclusions for them and a key out for us!
Are there any volunteers for some not biased commentary, analysis, wrap up, predictions for the finals games (once scheduling is set)? Would be good to get a post on the main page!!
On the road again so won't have access to TSLeagues until tomorrow. CIFC 1st week finals: D: Johnson, Harbrow, Suckling, MacKenzie (Gilbert) M: Heppell, Judd, Hartlett, Tyson (Hoskins-Elliot) R: McIntosh F: Martin, Wright, Tippett, Dixon (Dawes) I: Gaff, Horlin-Smith (Witts) In: Dixon Out: White The trip to Blanchetown holds fond memories for the boys, as they ran out comfortable winners there earlier in the season. Fingers crossed for a similar result this weekend against the Bunyips. YAD - not sure if it's consolation or not, but I think if Pearcedale's score stood they would have jumped over you into the 8.
It's a tough week, and the Smugglers look full strength so hoping to see some big scores from my superstars... DEF: Duffield, SD Thompson, R Thompson, Laird MID: Pendles, Prestia, Armitage, Pearce RUC: Big Tap FWD: Gray, Schulz, Mayne, Ballantyne INT: Giles, Bews (N Robertson)
YAD69 wrote: DamoH, TTT would go to 10th, Insider 9th & yad would be 8th. Sorry mate, obviously forgot to carry the one. It's a shame, having the three Island teams in the finals would have proven our (already known) superiority over those pretender mainlanders.