Dean.....VERY much appreciated all of the work you have put into this, thanks mate. Question - what's the criteria for the RS next season, in so much as 2015 rookies are concerned. How many games is too many to go around again? The likes of Stringer, having played 18 games is probably too many? But the likes of Jack Martin & Bonts, around 10-12 each, do they qualify again ? snoz
Simonoz wrote: Dean.....VERY much appreciated all of the work you have put into this, thanks mate. Question - what's the criteria for the RS next season, in so much as 2015 rookies are concerned. How many games is too many to go around again? The likes of Stringer, having played 18 games is probably too many? But the likes of Jack Martin & Bonts, around 10-12 each, do they qualify again ? snoz snoz,The ORFFA Rising Star criteria used this season was the same as the AFL Rising Star criteria. To be eligible a player must be under the age of 21 at January 1 of that year and must not have played more than 10 career games to the start of that year. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;]Under that criteria Bontempelli and Stringer would both be ineligible for 2015 with 16 and 28 career games respectively. Stringer only just snuck in for 2014 having played 10 games in 2013 before adding another 18 games in 2014. Jack Martin would also be ineligible, having played 11 games in 2014. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;]I can continue to be involved in the ORFFA Rising Star Award in 2015 but wont be able to spend as much time on it as I did in 2014 so before considering the eligibility criteria in too much detail for 2015 and if any changes are made we first need to check if the ORFFA Rising Star Award continues in 2015 or if someone else co-ordinates the Rising Star Award. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;]One option is for each ORFFA coach to post for each of their Rising Star players that played for their ORFFA club in a round, a) what their supercoach score was b) how much time they spent on the ground and c) if they were played out of position. This is step 1. On average each ORFFA club had just under 1 game (0.91 games to be exact), played by a Rising Star each round, so it wouldn't take long for each coach to do this each round. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] If most of the ORFFA coaches are happy to complete step 1 for their club I can then complete the rest of the process in the same way as this season. step 2 which is entering each club's ORFFA Rising Star stats into a spreadsheet and post the Round by Round ORFFA Rising Star scores, and then step 3 at the end of the season - provide Rising Star stats to all the coaches, request and tally the votes and prepare an article on the winner. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;]How many coaches would be willing to complete step 1 for their ORFFA club? <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;]If a number of coaches don't want to or can't complete step 1 we would need to consider other alternatives for the ORFFA Rising Star Award in 2015. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;]Dean
Happy to compile the Misfit's stats Dean, can also do fill in for others, where do you get the TOG stat? The only place I've seen (noticed) it is on the Freako pdf that gets sent out by CD..
You can get TOG from the AFL website. It's not in the default view but you can change the columns to display it.
JC wrote: You can get TOG from the AFL website. It's not in the default view but you can change the columns to display it. ta mate, love the new avatar
You've done a sterling job to get this up and running Dean. Prob not the ideal time to be asking for commitment but fwiw I am on board with providing the Lefties data on a weekly basis. I would suggest PM but not convinced this function is bumping to email anymore. Personally, I am in favour of the concept and am happy to chip in some admin to keep it afloat.
I'll be able to provide Cockies data. I reckon it's a good idea to share the load. but I'm defs still happy for you, Dean, to compile all of the data and do the writeups etc. thanks
Count me in Dean. Though we may need a reminder or two closer to the season starting in order to ensure we remember!!
dmandrews wrote: Simonoz wrote: Dean.....VERY much appreciated all of the work you have put into this, thanks mate. Question - what's the criteria for the RS next season, in so much as 2015 rookies are concerned. How many games is too many to go around again? The likes of Stringer, having played 18 games is probably too many? But the likes of Jack Martin & Bonts, around 10-12 each, do they qualify again ? snoz snoz,The ORFFA Rising Star criteria used this season was the same as the AFL Rising Star criteria. To be eligible a player must be under the age of 21 at January 1 of that year and must not have played more than 10 career games to the start of that year. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;]Under that criteria Bontempelli and Stringer would both be ineligible for 2015 with 16 and 28 career games respectively. Stringer only just snuck in for 2014 having played 10 games in 2013 before adding another 18 games in 2014. Jack Martin would also be ineligible, having played 11 games in 2014. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;]I can continue to be involved in the ORFFA Rising Star Award in 2015 but wont be able to spend as much time on it as I did in 2014 so before considering the eligibility criteria in too much detail for 2015 and if any changes are made we first need to check if the ORFFA Rising Star Award continues in 2015 or if someone else co-ordinates the Rising Star Award. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;]One option is for each ORFFA coach to post for each of their Rising Star players that played for their ORFFA club in a round, a) what their supercoach score was b) how much time they spent on the ground and c) if they were played out of position. This is step 1. On average each ORFFA club had just under 1 game (0.91 games to be exact), played by a Rising Star each round, so it wouldn't take long for each coach to do this each round. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] If most of the ORFFA coaches are happy to complete step 1 for their club I can then complete the rest of the process in the same way as this season. step 2 which is entering each club's ORFFA Rising Star stats into a spreadsheet and post the Round by Round ORFFA Rising Star scores, and then step 3 at the end of the season - provide Rising Star stats to all the coaches, request and tally the votes and prepare an article on the winner. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;][span style='padding: 0cm; border: 1pt none windowtext; background: white;]How many coaches would be willing to complete step 1 for their ORFFA club? <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;]If a number of coaches don't want to or can't complete step 1 we would need to consider other alternatives for the ORFFA Rising Star Award in 2015. <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;] <p style='margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt;]Dean With just under a week to go before the start of the AFL/ORFFA season I thought I better remind everyone about the ORFFA Rising Star award. As per my post above from a few months back I plan to continue overseeing the Rising Star Award but wont be able to spend as much time on it as I did last year. Several ORFFA coaches have already said that they can assist by completing Step 1 for their Rising Star eligible players and I can continue completing steps 2 and 3 in the same way as last year. Thanks to the coaches who have already responded in this thread. If you haven't responded in this thread can you please let me know if you are able to complete step 1 for your Rising Star players or if you have any alternative suggestions. As JC said in the thread the time on ground stat is available on the AFL website but not in the default setting. After the season opener between Carlton and Richmond I will provide instructions on how to get the TOG from the AFL website. In case anyone is wondering I will continue posting the Les W Medal votes in the same format as least season.
Len wrote: Hi Dean, to help avoid confusion, are you able to list by FA team the eligible players? Len Yes I will list the players that are eligible for the ORFFA Rising Star Award, however I don't think I will be able to provide the list for all players before the season starts. Before Thursday night's game I will list all the Carlton and Richmond players on an ORFFA list that are eligible for the Rising Star award and on Good Friday I will list all of the players eligible for ORFFA Rising Star award by ORFFA club.
As Carlton and Richmond play in the season opener on Thursday night I have listed players from these two clubs that are eligible for the 2015 ORFFA Rising Star Award below. The entire list of players eligible for the ORFFA Rising Star Award will be posted on Good Friday with the players listed in order by ORFFA club. <table border='0' cellpadding='0' cellspacing='0' width='621' style='width: 467pt;] <col width='154' style='width: 116pt;[/img] <col width='153' style='width: 115pt;[/img] <col width='96' style='width: 72pt;[/img] <col width='69' style='width: 52pt;[/img] <col width='75' style='width: 56pt;[/img] <col width='74' style='width: 56pt;[/img] <td class='xl63' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Name <td class='xl63' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]ORFFA Club <td class='xl63' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]2015 Pos <td class='xl63' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]AFL Club <td class='xl63' style='width: 56pt; text-align: left;]DOB <td class='xl63' style='width: 56pt; text-align: left;]AFL Games <td style='height: 15pt; text-align: left;] <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Clem Smith <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Darraweit Guim Dirigibles <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]M <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Carl <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]3/02/1996 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]0 <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Kamdyn Mcintosh <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Darraweit Guim Dirigibles <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]D <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Rich <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]3/04/1994 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]0 <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Patrick Cripps <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Gundagai Grasshoppers <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]M <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Carl <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]18/03/1995 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]3 <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Kristian Jaksch <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Marble Bar Misfits <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]D <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Carl <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]7/10/1994 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]7 <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Corey Ellis <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Mt Beauty Uglies <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]M <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Rich <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]9/10/1996 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]0 <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Ben Lennon <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Wagga Wagga Wombats <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]F <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Rich <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]5/07/1995 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]7 <tr height='32' style='height: 24pt;] <td class='xl64' style='height: 24pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Nicholas Graham <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Waikikamoocow Incorrigibles <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]M <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Carl <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]12/06/1994 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]10 <tr height='32' style='height: 24pt;] <td class='xl64' style='height: 24pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Reece McKenzie <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Waikikamoocow Incorrigibles <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]F <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Rich <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]28/03/1996 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]0 <td class='xl64' style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;]Dillon Viojo-Rainbow <td class='xl64' style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;]Whitsunday Warriors <td class='xl64' style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;]D <td class='xl64' style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;]Carl <td class='xl65' align='right' style='text-align: left;]8/02/1996 <td class='xl66' align='right' style='text-align: left;]0
dmandrews wrote: Len wrote: Hi Dean, to help avoid confusion, are you able to list by FA team the eligible players? Len Yes I will list the players that are eligible for the ORFFA Rising Star Award, however I don't think I will be able to provide the list for all players before the season starts. Before Thursday night's game I will list all the Carlton and Richmond players on an ORFFA list that are eligible for the Rising Star award and on Good Friday I will list all of the players eligible for ORFFA Rising Star award by ORFFA club. Perfect mate, eligibility has caused confusion previously..
dmandrews wrote: As Carlton and Richmond play in the season opener on Thursday night I have listed players from these two clubs that are eligible for the 2015 ORFFA Rising Star Award below. The entire list of players eligible for the ORFFA Rising Star Award will be posted on Good Friday with the players listed in order by ORFFA club. <table width='621' cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0' border='0' style='width: 467pt;] <col width='154' style='width: 116pt;[/img] <col width='153' style='width: 115pt;[/img] <col width='96' style='width: 72pt;[/img] <col width='69' style='width: 52pt;[/img] <col width='75' style='width: 56pt;[/img] <col width='74' style='width: 56pt;[/img] <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl63]Name <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl63]ORFFA Club <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl63]2015 Pos <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl63]AFL Club <td style='width: 56pt; text-align: left;' class='xl63]DOB <td style='width: 56pt; text-align: left;' class='xl63]AFL Games <td style='height: 15pt; text-align: left;] <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Clem Smith <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Darraweit Guim Dirigibles <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]M <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Carl <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]3/02/1996 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]0 <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Kamdyn Mcintosh <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Darraweit Guim Dirigibles <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]D <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Rich <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]3/04/1994 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]0 <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Patrick Cripps <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Gundagai Grasshoppers <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]M <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Carl <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]18/03/1995 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]3 <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Kristian Jaksch <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Marble Bar Misfits <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]D <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Carl <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]7/10/1994 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]7 <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Corey Ellis <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Mt Beauty Uglies <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]M <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Rich <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]9/10/1996 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]0 <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Ben Lennon <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Wagga Wagga Wombats <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]F <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Rich <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]5/07/1995 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]7 <tr height='32' style='height: 24pt;] <td style='height: 24pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Nicholas Graham <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Waikikamoocow Incorrigibles <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]M <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Carl <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]12/06/1994 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]10 <tr height='32' style='height: 24pt;] <td style='height: 24pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Reece McKenzie <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Waikikamoocow Incorrigibles <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]F <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Rich <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]28/03/1996 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]0 <td style='height: 15pt; width: 116pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Dillon Viojo-Rainbow <td style='width: 115pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Whitsunday Warriors <td style='width: 72pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]D <td style='width: 52pt; text-align: left;' class='xl64]Carl <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl65]8/02/1996 <td align='right' style='text-align: left;' class='xl66]0 Thanks Dean - that's a huge help. Looks like I'll have a couple of guys to track - best of luck to them if they get a game.