He will be a good player. Ross Lyon doesn't have a history of giving rookies a clear run early in their careers. If he starts, you'd have to expect vests which would mean slow burn for SC.

I'm confused about this result. Are Cripps and Cockatoo really so important? We're talking GAJ and Gray that will come in. Cheaper mids I'm looking at with them are Vandenberg and Blakely. Still decent options IMO.
Anyone got any feedback for me?

You bundled so many players together that it would be hard to settle on a single reason for the voting.

Some would have voted for No Ablett.
Some would have voted for Cripps ahead of any other rookies.

If you want to know a specific X v Y, post a question that isn't so complicated perhaps.

Yeah, good points, but it's the bundle that makes it. Difficult to judge some 1on1s in isolation, unless they are same price.
I set up the next poll of Lids v Gray to get some context for this vote. So many ppl are voting Gray over Lids, so what that says is that GAJ over Selwood is nowhere near as big an advantage as Cripps & Cockatoo is over cheaper options.

This may be right, but I'm kinda loathe to leave GAJ out now.

Neither.
Go a cheaper rookie and either keep the cash for future upgrades, or make some of your keepers better quality to begin with.

TU: Lamb
TU: Lonie

I think I like Lonie slightly more, but Lamb plays first therefore we won't know if Lonie will be sub if we pass on Lamb. Doubtful Lamb will be sub with his role in the team.

im of same opinion as you. Lonie > Lamb, but timing of games, may mean going with Lamb.